3 ms·
As a piece of rhetoric, it's not bad. I'm certainly sympathetic to the author's viewpoint. As a piece that gives any insight into the nature of money, it leaves
by javajosh 14y ago
As a piece of rhetoric, it's not bad. I'm certainly sympathetic to the author's viewpoint. As a piece that gives any insight into the nature of money, it leaves a lot to be desired. It is true that money is inextricably intertwined (gotta love that phrase, heh) with the political, social, and legal constructs that support it. And the notion that money is somehow encoded in a "web of obligation" rings true. But I guess I'm not really appalled by this, just like I'm not appalled by the fact that gravity doesn't let me fly, and certainly the idea that millionaires' wealth is not fluid because of peer pressure sounds like pure hogwash.
A discussion I'd like to see on HN revolves around a simple scenario. You live in a village, people only barter with each other. The village grows, and someone comes up with the idea that money would make it possible to avoid complex and difficult trades involving real goods. Money is essentially a convenience. But how do you do it? Even assuming that you have a completely trustworthy producer of currency, how, exactly, do you introduce money into the system? It is my belief that a great deal of ignorance is laid bare when you start thinking through the problems of rolling out a new currency like this.
Indeed, if and when we can see through this problem, we can evolve our little society further and faster, and understand how the various types of institutions we have evolved. Think of it as "economic embryology" - and just like real embryology yields some incredible insights into the adult organism, I think the economic embryology gedanken experiment can generate real insights into a mature economy.
- scarmig 14y agoThat's largely ahistorical, though: no historian or anthropologist thinks this is how money arose. You sometimes see shadow currencies evolve out of the breakdown of liberal capitalist societies--in prisons, times of famine, mass inflation, etc.--to make barter more fluid. The picture history paints, however, is one where money is typically invented by a ruling elite to use as a unit of account and as a way to extract taxes from the peasantry to fund military ventures.
- javajosh 14y agoThought experiments are ahistorical and arealistic. Yet they are still important tools for understanding things. Go figure.
- halhen 14y ago> how do you do it? In Capital volume 1, Marx paints the following logical progression. Whether it carries any historical truth, I don't know. (Note: there are many more nuances to it, and you perhaps need to wrestle the original source to get it all) To establish a single unit of measurement: a. The simple, isolated, or accidental form of value: Commodities are exchangeable with other commodities, e.g. 20 yards of linen = 1 coat. b. The Total or Expanded Form of Value: a commodity is exchangeable with any other commodity, e.g. 20 yards of linen = 1 coat or = 10 lb tea or = 40 lb coffee or = 1 quarter of corn or = 2 ounces of gold or = etc. c. The general form of value: Any of said quantities of commodities are exchangeable with the original commodity, e.g. 1 coat, 10 lb tea, 40 lb coffee, 1 quarter of corn, and 2 ounces of gold, are worth 20 yards of linen. d. The money form: One, or a few, commodities become either the de factor or the legal "universal equivalent" commodity in which exchange-value is measured. This universal requires some properties (I'm sure I have forgotten several): * It must be uniform. Not all horses are equal, so horses are no good. * It must be divisible and capable of quantitative differentiation. Half a work horse is less worth than half of a whole, and two halves of work horses does not equal one. Horses are not good for a second reason. * As trade expands geographically, the value of the universal equivalent needs to be universally recognized. Horses for seamen? More inconvenient than it should be. * The universal equivalent should not deteriorate. Horses die. They really are no good for this. Instead, precious metals fulfill these qualities. And just as we use dollars and cents, gold and silver can be used to differentiate between different magnitudes of value. (Note: gold and silver still has values as commodities, which determine the amount of stuff you get for them. See the initial points.) Still, they do have some problems. They require measurements and tools to divide. It's not really convenient to go into Starbucks with a lump of silver to carve the price for a coffee. So coins are minted, containing the proper amount of each metal. New problems arise. Cheaters carve metals from the coins to melt and create new. Wear and tear cheapens the coins. So bills and coins are created as symbols of silver and gold, but backed by them. The actual precious metal reside elsewhere, and the bill is just a proof of ownership. Now, those countries and owners who control precious metals get significant power. They can withhold or flood the marked at their whim. No good, says the other countries. So when currency is sufficiently recognized as a means of payment, one can remove the actual backing and keep the bills and coins only. And while we're on it, why bother with the bills at all? A balance in a computer is just as good, right?
- markvdb 14y agoNo need to experiment. Anthropologists and historians have taken a closer look at this and pierced through the barter economy myth. You might want to read the relevant chapters of David Graeber's book "Debt: the first 5000 years".