4 ms·
Food and healthcare are both inelastic demands, yes. But that doesn't mean they are comparable. I have 8 hours between hunger spikes; plenty of time to shop aro
by sliverstorm 14y ago
Food and healthcare are both inelastic demands, yes. But that doesn't mean they are comparable. I have 8 hours between hunger spikes; plenty of time to shop around. I know when I am going to be hungry, and I will be hungry again soon.
The issue as I see it with healthcare is the the nature of the beast itself. When you are bleeding from the femoral artery, you don't have time to shop around, and you don't know when it will happen. Additionally, it is a rare event, unlike your drive for food.
- MoreMoschops 14y agoWhen you have one of the big ticket items that they make the big money on, such as cancer, you have a lot of time to shop around.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoI disagree that healthcare is an inelastic demand, it's obviously quite elastic. There are levels of service and of care. Take something like a broken femur for example. One person may opt for a cast and crutches and little else while someone else may opt for a motorized wheelchair and extensive hands-on rehabilitation therapy afterward. Or look at, say, prosthetics. There are amazing cutting-edge almost bionic prosthetic hands and legs these days, but does it make sense to bankrupt the public in order to guarantee everyone access to those who might want them? Or just look at something as simple as diet and exercise (what we know to have one of the biggest impacts on health), one person may be able to afford a personal chef and dietitian who can plan all their meals and to hire a personal trainer to keep them in shape, but many wouldn't be able to afford that or even necessarily want it. The notion that everyone should be guaranteed equal health outcomes is a very seductive one, but once you start digging into the details it falls apart quite rapidly.
- LeeHunter 14y ago"The notion that everyone should be guaranteed equal health outcomes is a very seductive one, but once you start digging into the details it falls apart quite rapidly." Falls apart exactly how? Seems to work fine in just about every country that's tried it (which is most of the first world). Mind you, it's not really the health outcome that's guaranteed (obviously that's going to depend on individual constitution, age and lifestyle) but access to the same level of care is seen as a given. In my town recently there was a minor scandal when a pro hockey player showed up with a game injury at a local emergency ward and went to the head of the line. The hospital had to scramble to explain that his injury went through normal triage. You talk about bankrupting the public, but clearly it's the far more expensive US system that is bankrupting the public (along with providing worse outcomes overall). For those of use who have grown up with publicly funded healthcare, a fully private system seems primitive, barbaric and inhumane equivalent to having firefighting or police services exclusively for those who can afford it.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThis explains why Canadians, including MPs, sometimes come to the US for care, and why the Queen of England went to a private hospital when she developed gastroenteritis, right? It's silly to imagine that there isn't or shouldn't be a relationship between level of care and cost of care, even if we desire for the costs of most common life-saving care to be "socialized" in some way. Demanding that all care be the best possible care is a non-starter because that's clearly not financially feasible. Some folks can afford to spend multiples of the average per capita GDP on their health care, and that's just not physically possible for everyone to do. As for your straw man about a "fully private system", I made no mention of that, nor have I advocated such. I was merely making an isolated point. You can put your pitchforks back in the shed and put down your "libertarianism = somalia!" signs. Our system is clearly broken, but the idea that other systems aren't also broken in various ways is naive. There's no silver bullet that will solve the problems of cost and access to health care, and that includes the extraordinarily naive idea of just making "government" pay for it all.
- snowwrestler 14y agoThis is where the concept of health care "insurance" makes sense. We have car insurance and homeowner insurance for the same reason--to cover sudden, unexpected events. But modern health care "insurance" also covers the payment of goods and services that do NOT meet sudden and unexpected events. A huge portion of the health care industry services chronic ailments. Hunger could be considered a chronic ailment--it is not urgent, but must be managed at all times.
- sliverstorm 14y agoYeah, I agree. Things like birth control seem entirely at odds with the "insurance" model. I haven't a problem with subsidized birth control, but maybe such services should be part of a separate program?