5 ms·
The author experienced Clinical Death[1] and not permanent death. However, it's interesting now that we are close to singularity, death may be no longer death.
by csomar 14y ago
The author experienced Clinical Death[1] and not permanent death. However, it's interesting now that we are close to singularity, death may be no longer death.
What does it mean to die if I upload your brain and make another process of yourself? Is death related to the body or losing consciousness?
Finally, dying is like sleeping. You are not around when you are dead. The author certainly got a shock from the things that happened to him and the thoughts of not existing any more and not experiencing death per se.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clinical_death http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clinical_death
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoThe sleep thing is a very bad argument on issues of death. I don't know about the rest of you, but I was always under the impression it's normal to drift in and out of various partial forms of consciousness immediately before, during, and after sleep. If dying was like sleeping, it would include the occasional moment of waking up to notice how comfortable your blanket is, roll over, and fall back adead. What does it mean to die if I upload your brain and make another process of yourself? Is death related to the body or losing consciousness? Well, that mostly depends on how you've defined "to die". I can easily imagine that the neo-Victorian Phyle will pass a law banning brain-copying after clinical death as an abomination, for instance. The thing about playing God is that you have to start writing your own rules.
- krapp 14y agoWhat does it mean to die if I upload your brain and make another process of yourself? Is death related to the body or losing consciousness? Assuming that something we will retroactively refer to as singlulary ever occurs, and that we are close to singluarity, and that it ever takes a form which leads to some kind of ubiquitous 'upload' of a brain model that somehow acts and reacts as a brain in a skull in meatspace would (and all of these qualifiers are debatable,) you still die. In the future the notion of what it means to be alive, and human, and dead, may be reinterpreted so that these models are considered to be, essentially, the same being as their original. But this redefinition would be semantics. Nothing frees you from the absolute and irrevocable nature of your death, in this or any other universe, ever. The post-singularity upload is still a copy, however good, and at this point the analogy of copying minds as software breaks down, because the mind isn't separate from the brain, and whether or not there's an entity on the wires which believes itself to be you, you are still no less dead.
- gnaritas 14y ago> you still die. Uh, no. > In the future the notion of what it means to be alive, and human, and dead, may be reinterpreted so that these models are considered to be, essentially, the same being as their original. You haven't considered that more likely, we'll become so augmented with additional abilities that the pure natural "you" will no longer feel like you even to yourself. You consciousness will outgrow your biological body even though it's rooted in it and at some point, "you" even to yourself will be mostly machine anyway so when the biology finally dies off, it will still be the original "you" left in the machine. Losing the biology will make it no less you than losing an arm. > The post-singularity upload is still a copy It simply won't be an upload, "you" will already be a cyborg mostly made of machine anyway.
- krapp 14y agoIf you're talking about some kind of Ship of Theseus scenario where the brain is gradually replaced bit by bit with something more permanent then... I don't know. I wouldn't argue that someone with an artificial arm is less than a full human so logically someone with an artificial brain should be just as human. But then, the function of the arm is not to house the entirely of human consciousness, where that of the brain is. The arm isn't you, but the brain is you. To me, if you replace that, you might replicate the function but (as with the arm) it's still one thing replacing the other (and implying the first thing, being an arm, or a life, is no longer there.)
- gnaritas 14y agoNo, I'm saying the consciousness will actually outgrown the bounds of the brain so completely that when the brain itself finally dies you won't consider it anything more than a small appendage anyway. The brain isn't going to be replaced bit by bit, it's going to be subsumed into a much larger consciousness. You seem to have this notion that the consciousness will be either in the brain or in the machine, I think that notion is fundamentally flawed, consciousness will expand to include every tool and sense available in both hardware and wetware, it cannot and will not be bound. Your sense of "self" is going to include every hardware upgrade you have; when you can Google with a thought, you will feel like part of you dies if that's turned off as it will quickly become part of your consciousness.