2 ms·
I think a lot of the backlash comes from a misunderstanding of how this affects prior art. The name "first-to-file" makes it seem like you can take some inventi
by TheCoelacanth 14y ago
I think a lot of the backlash comes from a misunderstanding of how this affects prior art. The name "first-to-file" makes it seem like you can take some invention that has been published but not patented, and patent it, preventing the actual inventor from using the invention. That is not the case.
Only the inventor is allowed to file a patent. Under a first-to-file system, anything that has been made public can still be used as prior art to invalidate a patent.
- gamblor956 14y agoAnything...except the inventor's own prior disclosures about the invention made within a period of time immediately prior to the patent application (I think up to a year before the patent filing but I'm not sure.)
- Gormo 14y agoSo what happens if the inventor decides to publish the invention in a manner that implies that it's free for others to use without any license or royalty, but then, a year later, decides to file for a patent? Would the use of the invention by others invalidate the patent application? Would the patent be granted, but unenforceable due to the prior public release of the invention being construed as estoppel that creates a general license to the invention? Or would the inventor, armed with a new patent, be able to tell everyone already using the invention that they now have to pay a license fee to continue using it?