3 ms·
I agree that people usually think of Monsanto suits in conjunction with plant patents, but the point that the article raises is valid. How can one tell? If yo
by bediger4000 14y ago
I agree that people usually think of Monsanto suits in conjunction with plant patents, but the point that the article raises is valid. How can one tell? If you can tell, don't we all owe money to the heirs of whoever invented corn, and whoever invented wheat? After all, copying is theft...
- tptacek 14y agoLike I said, if you want to argue that there is no possible validity to a plant patent, that's something I'm not prepared to litigate. I'm just saying that accidentally planting a RR plant in your garden or even your commercial farm probably won't get you in legal trouble, because you aren't going to spray them with glyphosphate.
- bediger4000 14y agoHow on earth did you get the idea that I'm arguing against the validity of a legitimate, duely legislated and properly instituted legal entity like a plant patent? In point of fact, I argued the exact opposite. I feel quite offended that you attribute the exact opposite of what I wrote to me. I wrote that copying is theft, and I implied that we all owe some money to the heirs of the inventors of agriculture (there were probably at least 5 such inventors) because of the continued use of said inventor's property. What's your beef with that? Are you a pirate, or one of these anti-Intellectual Property heretics/crazies?
- tptacek 14y agoI'm afraid you may have figured me out.
- greenyoda 14y agoCorn and wheat were domesticated from their wild ancestors thousands of years ago (agriculture dates back about 10000 years), so nobody could get a patent on corn and wheat in general: there's prior art that predates the existence of patents by thousands of years. Copying something that's in the public domain is certainly not theft. Now, if you're talking about specific varieties of recently genetically modified corn or wheat, there might be patents that apply to those. Also, patents eventually expire, so we don't owe royalties to the heirs of patent holders forever.