4 ms·
David Moon's Programming Language for Old Timers
- gruseom 18y agoWow, this is interesting on many levels. The slides from ILC are a good overview: http://users.rcn.com/david-moon/PLOT/Moon-ILC09.pdf http://users.rcn.com/david-moon/PLOT/Moon-ILC09.pdf. They contain this fascinating statement: Traditionally, code walking has required ad hoc code to understand every “special form.” It is better to have a well-defined, object-oriented interface to the Abstract Syntax Tree, scopes, and definitions. This is why objects are better than S-expressions as a representation for program source code. I have never heard anyone point to s-expressions as the reason code walkers are hard to write in Lisp (and they are, at least in CL).
- Hexstream 18y agoFrom the intro: "PLOT sports a more conventional-looking syntax than classic Lisp." Must... not... dismiss out-of-hand! (Historically, attempts to give Lisp a more conventional syntax have been made of fail)
- lincolnq 18y agoThis is true. But David Moon is fairly famous, having worked on Lisp, CLOS, Dylan (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Moon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Moon) and he was immortalized in the hacker koan: (From http://catb.org/jargon/html/koans.html http://catb.org/jargon/html/koans.html) One day a student came to Moon and said, "I understand how to make a better garbage collector. We must keep a reference count of the pointers to each of the cons." Moon patiently told the student the following story: "One day a student came to Moon and said, 'I understand how to make a better garbage collector...'" So I'm inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt, at least for now. ;-) edit: fixed typo in quote
- jjs 18y ago> We must keep a reference count of the pointers to each of the cans." CONS
- mahmud 18y agoTietelman was also famous and ran his own Lisp machine company, InterLisp, and probably had wads of cash and the social clout to push whatever he wanted. His Lisp with English-like syntax had a Futile And Ill Life.
- lg 18y ago"each cons" wasn't a typo...
- scott_s 18y agoTake a look at some examples: http://users.rcn.com/david-moon/PLOT/page-5.html http://users.rcn.com/david-moon/PLOT/page-5.html Norvig as pointed out that Python can end up looking like Lisp with the parenthesis replaced with indentations (http://norvig.com/python-lisp.html http://norvig.com/python-lisp.html). I think this comes even closer.
- mahmud 18y agoCMU/Apple Dylan; they wasted a perfectly good CLOS successor and a kickass user-interface framework not to mention a great type-system, on a non-Lisp syntax. The rest, as they say, was history. An obscure and long forgotten history. Lisp doesn't like to be dressed up.
- Hexstream 18y agoI don't understand why they'd throw up everything in the air just because they screwed up the syntax. Wouldn't it have been easy to make a proper s-expression front-end to the environment and keep the rest of the good stuff?
- gcv 18y agoDylan started with an s-expression syntax. For several years, it looked like Scheme with CLOS bolted on top. The language eventually switched to a conventional infix notation. It actually looks pretty good to my s-expression-addled eyes, except that "end" blocks explicitly describe the block being ended, e.g., "end if", "end class", "end function". (To any Dylan experts in the audience: if that's optional, feel free to correct me.) Dylan has not exactly failed, since it still has an active development team which makes regular releases, but it has not achieved popularity. Dylan has macros, a real condition system, and a CLOS-type object system --- a way better feature list than Ruby's or Python's, IMO.
- Zak 18y agoLisp doesn't like to be dressed up. I think the real problem is that people who understand Lisp understand that Lisp programs are Lisp data structures, and want them to look that way. People who don't get it won't be drawn to the language for its unconventional object system or condition handling. People who are won't be scared off by unconventional syntax.
- calambrac 18y agoIs there an implementation available anywhere to play with? Or is this still in the design and discussion phase? I'd love to play around with this, it seems like a clear, solid distillation of a lot of ideas.
- joubert 18y agoWhen David presented this during the ILC last week at MIT, he said this is simply a hobby and experiment and that he doesn't have plans to release an implementation.
- jrockway 18y agoHe also said that if someone wants to implement it, they should. He just doesn't want to be that someone, since he can't spend enough time on it to get it right.
- scott_s 18y agoI'm glad this made its way onto the main page. I suppose timing and headlines matter more than I thought: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=530710 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=530710
- nostrademons 18y agoShould've known that putting "David Moon" in the title here will get you at least twice as many votes...which will get you more votes in turn...
- msie 18y agoIndentation is meaningful just like in Python: "There are two special considerations for newlines in the syntax. The purpose of this is to allow nesting structure to be indicated by indentation rather than by any kind of explicit bracketing."