4 ms·
This is what farms will look like in the future
- galago 14y agoIs the author suggesting that food is going to get really expensive?
- showerst 14y agoSomething I've never understood about those cool looking vertical farm concepts is water management. Doesn't it take a TON of energy to pump enough water to irrigate a field up 50 stories?
- maxerickson 14y agoI checked the math on a post yesterday that compared the energy in a gallon of gas to the energy stored by 3500 gallons of water at a height of 1 kilometer. As far as I could see, the math was right. That doesn't account for pumping losses and all that, but it is a nice check on intuition (for reference, 1 gallon gas is equivalent to 33 kWh, ignoring our inability to extract that much useful energy).
- lotsofcows 14y agoThey're supposed to be self contained. Top up water is collected from rain fall. No water is supposed to leave the building.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoOne wonders if you can vaporize it at the bottom and condense it out of the air at the top, but yes there clearly would have to be some sort of energy input to move water. One could imagine a sort of bucket brigade kind of thing where water heading down, was collecting in buckets which were lifting a slightly lower mass of water up (or equivalent mass with a an energy injection to cover the difference). But I don't think anyone submitted these designs as practical farms, more like Farms that look futuristic at the expense of being implementable :-).
- protomyth 14y agoCalifornia needs to put some effort behind desalination plants or else they will lose some of the most productive farms in the country and a whole wine industry.
- bobwaycott 14y agoI seriously doubt our food-producing future will look all kinds of architectural sexy.
- jdietrich 14y agoNo, no they won't, anyone who says they will lacks a grade-school understanding of plant biology. Plants eat sunlight. With adequate irrigation, light is the key limiting factor on plant growth. Stacking plants vertically is a very expensive waste of time, because you're not gathering any more solar energy than if you just planted them at ground-level. You're just spreading the same amount of light between more plants - plants that are housed in a very expensive building and that are impossible to tend or harvest in an efficient manner. The future of farming already exists. It's in southern Spain, around towns like El Ejido and Almeria. These areas look white in satellite images, not because of any geological feature but because they're absolutely covered in polytunnels - hundreds of thousands of greenhouses, creating a humid microclimate in an arid but sunny region, to supply salad vegetables to Europe year-round. http://goo.gl/maps/WrZ5j http://goo.gl/maps/WrZ5j
- ChuckMcM 14y agohave to vote you up just for the cool link. The 'contest' was really about visualization and design. Not really about actual usability :-) That said, there is a growing aquaponics movement in California which seeks to create nearly water neutral farms. I keep hoping to find one of those scaled up to something like the Spaniards have done but in Calfornia's central valley.
- mapt 14y agoThis is literally among the dumbest environmentalist ideas out there. It's a tragedy it gets so much attention because that enthusiasm could be oriented towards advocacy of things which actually make a difference. A napkin calculation a while back factoring in the cost of farmland, light, land, and skyscraper construction showed approximately a 60,000x cost difference per pound of crops between purpose-build skyscraper-type vertical farming startup costs, and prime Iowa farmland. I'm not exaggerating. Compare irrigated desert land under intensive greenhouse cultivation with skyscrapers, and you're still at hundreds or thousands of times more expensive. The most sizable vertical farm at present is either a natural-light "bookshelf style" setup in Singapore which does absolutely nothing for land use by shading other land, and grows a trivial amount of crops, or a artificially-lit 30x30m area on Chiba University operated purely for research purposes, which sells its products on the side. When someone says "X is planned for Chicago", that actually means something to some of us, something other than "An undergrad design student asked for creative solutions to save the world came up with a pretty render that any architect, engineer, farmer, or businessman would laugh at on close examination". I would ask the green energy sites to stop lying to our faces on this topic, necessitating stories like this [1]. The only way this kind of solution is remotely feasible is when your product is marijuana, and it costs $1000/lb. Expensive niche herbs like basil and wasabi may be able to grow economically in a climate controlled hydroponic system... but they can only pay warehouse rent if that, not skyscraper rent. We owe the promotion of this concept to Dickson Despommier [2], a tenured professor of public health / environmental health sciences at Columbia University in Manhattan. Take one of the two most geographically and economically scarce land markets in the country, and apply "locavore" principles, and this stupidity is what you get. To the people believing because a render was created and it was "planned" that this means they can absolve their share of environmental white guilt for living in a neighborhood without any trees or permeable surfaces... Stop promoting this, please. Tens of square miles of city displaces thousands of square miles of suburb, and you're living at 1/10th the resource intensity of the rest of the country by not driving everywhere. Farmland is not this scarce, and transportation for food is not this expensive. The breathless enthusiasm of the green bloggers which are paid per post and have no formal science training past middle school has brought this concept to the forefront again and again. I've been shouting at my computer for nigh on ten years now and it will not die. [1] http://www.businessgreen.com/bg/james-blog/1810325/so-las-vegas-getting-vertical-farm http://www.businessgreen.com/bg/james-blog/1810325/so-las-ve... [2] http://www.verticalfarm.com/ http://www.verticalfarm.com/