4 ms·
Google Reader is irreplaceable, it is not only about reading RSS. That is the easy part. It is about going back in time and accessing all past feeds in an organ
by wslh 14y ago
Google Reader is irreplaceable, it is not only about reading RSS. That is the easy part. It is about going back in time and accessing all past feeds in an organized way (it is difficult to rebuilt that from crawling and web scraping). If you add a blog now you can read articles that are not present in the current feed.
Google Reader is the core of my information diet. Not twitter. Thousands of blogs starred, liked, and commented. An interesting feature that you couldn't replace is automatic translation: reading a russian blog asmit was written in english. Once I shared one of its articles and one friend asked me if I knew russian or if it was a joke my share! Because obviously the share was in the original language.
Google is evil. While I can understand a business decision, there are ways to hand it over to other companies or organizations.
I share some of my previous criticism:
- Extraction of Main Text Content Using the Google Reader NoAPI: http://blog.databigbang.com/extraction-of-main-text-content/ http://blog.databigbang.com/extraction-of-main-text-content/
-Google Search NoAPI: http://blog.databigbang.com/google-search-no-api/ http://blog.databigbang.com/google-search-no-api/
- The Data Portability Fact Sheet: http://blog.databigbang.com/the-data-portability-fact-sheet/ http://blog.databigbang.com/the-data-portability-fact-sheet/
- Reverse Engineering and the Cloud: http://blog.nektra.com/main/2012/06/01/reverse-engineering-and-the-cloud/ http://blog.nektra.com/main/2012/06/01/reverse-engineering-a...
- TillE 14y ago> It is about going back in time and accessing all past feeds in an organized way Yes, exactly. Google Reader is literally the only way to find past episodes of some podcasts - the files are still up, but after a site redesign nothing else links to them.
- nl 14y agoWait.. so they have a service that in your words is so good it is irreplaceable.. and taking it away makes them evil? That's pretty strong!
- wslh 14y agoYes, their historical data can't be rebuilt. A little bit like what happened with USENET and Google buying DejaNews. Nobody has that data.
- nl 14y agoSo go and grab the data you care about while it's there? I'm trying to understand why Google suddenly gets responsibility for archiving the entire internet for incompetent websites.
- tomjen3 14y agoBecause that is what googles mission is? To index all the worlds information and make it universually useful? Oh right, these days it is making shitty copies of facebook.
- aw3c2 14y agoNo, Google's mission is to make money. Everything else is optional.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoI thought their copy of Facebook is pretty good, or at least better than the original.
- _delirium 14y agoIt's unclear to me if they're also discontinuing the Google Feed API: https://developers.google.com/feed/ https://developers.google.com/feed/ This is quite valuable because it includes historical data, including stuff that's dropped off the currently available RSS feeds (many sites only list recent posts in their feeds).
- lobster_johnson 14y agoAccording to the ToS at https://developers.google.com/feed/terms https://developers.google.com/feed/terms: Google will announce if we intend to discontinue or make backwards incompatible changes to this API or Service. We will use commercially reasonable efforts to continue to operate the Google Feed API without these changes until April 20, 2015, unless (as Google determines in its reasonable good faith judgment): * required by law or third party relationship (including if there is a change in applicable law or relationship), or * doing so could create a security risk or substantial economic or material technical burden. This Deprecation Policy doesn't apply to versions, features, and functionality labeled as "experimental." Of course, who knows what "commercially reasonable efforts" really mean.
- lobster_johnson 14y agoOh, and it looks like the feed API may not be used to save anything; Google's API ToS [1] document has the following text: Unless expressly permitted by the content owner or by applicable law, you agree that you will not, and will not permit your end users to, do the following with content returned from the APIs: * Scrape, build databases or otherwise create permanent copies of such content, or keep cached copies longer than permitted by the cache header; * Copy, translate, modify, create a derivative work of, sell, lease, lend, convey, distribute, publicly display or sublicense to any third party; * Misrepresent the source or ownership; or * Remove, obscure, or alter any copyright, trademark or other proprietary rights notices, falsify or delete any author attributions, legal notices or other labels of the origin or source of material. The first two bullet points are the ones that apply. You can't use the feed API to fetch a bunch of feeds and make them available through an app, for example. [1] https://developers.google.com/terms/ https://developers.google.com/terms/
- rpgmaker 14y agoI believe this is called getting "scroogled".
- fauigerzigerk 14y agoIt is about going back in time and accessing all past feeds... I don't think Reader can find anything that Google search doesn't know. Using site:sitename.com in a regular Google search should bring up past entries as well.
- sp332 14y agoReader actually archives feeds, so there are a lot of defunct pages in Reader that Search can't find.
- wslh 14y agoAlso, it is strange that they fund driverless cars but close Google Reader! why not contract a small team of interns to keep the site running?