3 ms·
Thanks for beating me to make the same point. There is an astonishing lack of careful validation studies of many kinds of "scientific" evidence often referred t
by tokenadult 18y ago
Thanks for beating me to make the same point. There is an astonishing lack of careful validation studies of many kinds of "scientific" evidence often referred to in criminal trials. Basically, the "expert" gets on the witness stand, says what the prosecutor wants said, and it's a rare defense attorney who has the resources to offer rebuttal evidence on the same issue.
The common-law rule of handwriting identification is that it doesn't require special expertise, but only familiarity with someone's handwriting. In other words, even though I don't purport to have any specialized training in handwriting identification, I could (if the case required such evidence) be called to testify, "Yeah, that looks like my wife's handwriting; I've seen hundreds of examples of things she has written, and this looks just her usual handwriting." You could do the same for anyone whose handwriting is familiar to you.
- cubix 18y agoWhile reading this it occurred to me that I couldn't identify the handwriting of even those closest to me, with the possible exception of my parents, since our written communication is almost always online.