3 ms·
> The patent system shouldn't guarantee some kind of monetary reward. If it does, it sets up the wrong incentives. They don't, unless people use it and the pat
by pc86 14y ago
> The patent system shouldn't guarantee some kind of monetary reward. If it does, it sets up the wrong incentives.
They don't, unless people use it and the patent holder wants to charge for licensing.
- bediger4000 14y agoThe comment to which I responded seemed to take the view that spending a bunch of money on discovering or inventing something should more-or-less be automatically rewarded with at least a portion of the "intellectual property" rights. That's the concept I wanted to rebut. I don't have facts at hand, but I imagine that like any other thing (starting a business, writing a book, creating an App) 99.9% of patents result in no monetary gain whatsoever. But if we're going to go all in on the property aspects of patents, then I think that morally and ethically, we have to give an independent inventor a share of the property. Anything else just looks arbitrary, and leads to disrespect of patents, "intellectual property" and The Law in general.