3 ms·
"I disagree. Unless BTC becomes the only common currency, you'd end up with more distributed wealth, since the holders of BTC aren't exactly the biggest holders
by Nursie 14y ago
"I disagree. Unless BTC becomes the only common currency, you'd end up with more distributed wealth, since the holders of BTC aren't exactly the biggest holders of USD or EUR."
This is why I said if it became common currency. --edit-- as A lot of bitcoin folks seem to think would be a good idea! If it stays a minority interest like gold then the particular problem of widening wealth disparity is not really an issue. But that doesn't seem to be the aim of many in the BTC community - they want society to adopt BTC or something very close to BTC as a main currency, because they think the limited supply model would be a good thing in this situation, which I think it would not.
"By the way, how does the drop in prices relative to BTC kill lending?"
Err, because if BTC are always going up in value, why would I bother lending them?
As a borrower of currency with small, controlled inflation I pay a percentage in interest. This is eased by tomorrow's money being worth slightly less than today's.
As a lender I need to lend or otherwise invest to maintain value, and lending with an interest rate a little above inflation (and a little more to account for risk) is a good way to do this.
With a deflationary currency the burden on the borrower increases massively as tomorrow's currency is worth more and you'll have to do more to repay it.
As a lender I'm not going to lend at a flat or negative interest rate because it's easier and lower risk just to hang on to the coins.
"tech devices are cheaper every year, from that argument, shouldn't it mean there's a great incentive not to buy them?"
Because they're useful and they're not the same every year?
Also there is a small disincentive to buying computers when you can get more for your money if you hang on a bit.
- icebraining 14y agobecause if BTC are always going up in value, why would I bother lending them? Because you'd get more of them (just like now)? The only difference is that instead of having to cover inflation, any positive rate would give you profit over just holding them. As a borrower of currency with small, controlled inflation I pay a percentage in interest. This is eased by tomorrows money being slightly less than todays. But it's not eased, because as you say in the next paragraph, the lender prices in the inflation in that percentage. How do you benefit from USD being 3% cheaper, if the interest is 3% higher because of it? Only unexpected (not accounted for) inflation benefits the borrower. As a lender, you wouldn't lend a little above inflation, but a little above 0% to get the same returns. With a deflationary currency the burden of the borrower increases massively as tomorrows currency is worth more But the interest rates are dropped to account for that fact. As a lender I'm not going to lend at a flat or negative interest rate Oh, with that I can agree: negative or zero interest lending would stop. But that's hardly all lending, and it's not even clear if we want to encourage it.
- Nursie 14y ago"Because you'd get more of them (just like now)? The only difference is that instead of having to cover inflation, any positive rate would give you profit over just holding them." But you must charge a positive rate, which means the gap between deflation and rate charge may have to be huge. --edit-- And the bigger the gap (the more deflation there is) the higher the rate of positive interest you would want to charge to represent the risk that the person can't pay back, and the relatively high income to be gained by doing nothing. "But it's not eased, because as you say in the next paragraph, the lender prices in the inflation in that percentage. How do you benefit from USD being 3% cheaper, if the interest is 3% higher because of it? Only unexpected (not accounted for) inflation benefits the borrower." See above. A positive rate must be charged for it to be worthwhile, even if this is so far above deflation it's not funny. "But the interest rates are dropped to account for that fact." Yes, but they have an absolute cutoff. --edit-- Also what's my incentive, at the moment my stash of cash is losing value by holding it. It's (almost) 100% risk-free with an (almost) guarantee'd small loss in value. If you invent an implement (let's call it bitcoin) with the same risk profile as cash but an (almost) guarantee'd gain in value, many investors would just invest in cash. I know I would. "Oh, with that I can agree: negative or zero interest lending would stop. But that's hardly all lending, and it's not even clear if we want to encourage it." I'm not sure negative or zero lending is a thing at the moment... And I'm pretty sure we do want to encourage investment over hoarding, monetary velocity generally being considered to be a good thing, sitting on piles of cash which give you an ever greater fortune/stake in the economy just by holding them... I don't think that can be healthy for an economy.