6 ms·
I'd rather transition to a system where if two people try to file for the same thing within a few months or a year of each other, neither one gets it because it
by Nursie 14y ago
I'd rather transition to a system where if two people try to file for the same thing within a few months or a year of each other, neither one gets it because it's probably pretty obvious.
- natermer 14y agoI'd like to transition to a system were a anonymous bureaucrat in Washington doesn't get to go out and annihilate innovative businesses because some competing monolithic corporation was the first one to pay his employer off.
- rplnt 14y agoWhat if both of them put real effort (money) into research and arrived at similar/same place? Should it be dismissed as well? Or is there something as joint patent?
- Nursie 14y agoMaybe a joint patent, if they can agree to cooperate. Like naughty children, either you share nicely or nobody's having any cake! :)
- bediger4000 14y agoI think in that case, the answer is "too bad, so sad". The patent system shouldn't guarantee some kind of monetary reward. If it does, it sets up the wrong incentives. Independent invention should be a sign that the idea isn't worth patenting, that it was "in the air" at the time.
- pc86 14y ago> The patent system shouldn't guarantee some kind of monetary reward. If it does, it sets up the wrong incentives. They don't, unless people use it and the patent holder wants to charge for licensing.
- bediger4000 14y agoThe comment to which I responded seemed to take the view that spending a bunch of money on discovering or inventing something should more-or-less be automatically rewarded with at least a portion of the "intellectual property" rights. That's the concept I wanted to rebut. I don't have facts at hand, but I imagine that like any other thing (starting a business, writing a book, creating an App) 99.9% of patents result in no monetary gain whatsoever. But if we're going to go all in on the property aspects of patents, then I think that morally and ethically, we have to give an independent inventor a share of the property. Anything else just looks arbitrary, and leads to disrespect of patents, "intellectual property" and The Law in general.
- jmatthew3 14y agoIf two people invented the same thing together (or, more commonly, one person invents feature A, and another invents feature B, where both feature A and feature B are part of one invention), then they are joint inventors (and without an assignment or an obligation to assign, they are both joint owners). On the other hand, if two people invent the same thing separately (e.g., similar research goals at two competing pharmaceutical companies), then the first to file gets the application. It still must be an enabling disclosure, though. That is, it has to teach the public how to make and use the invention.
- GotAnyMegadeth 14y agoThen you could stop each others patents just by filing a copy...
- Nursie 14y agoWell yeah, the rules would have to be a bit more complex than that, but do you not like the general idea? Because I think a whole load of really obvious rubbish gets patented at the moment, but I do think the foundations of the patent system and the utility of patents ought to be salvaged.
- roc 14y agoYou wouldn't know what your competitors are filing within months of it happening and then have any opportunity to do anything about it. Applications are only published to the public either 18 months after the earliest priority date or after the patent has been granted. The only other time you might know what they were up to is if they made a public disclosure about the technology. But as that has implications for their own filing strategy, they're not likely to do that in a way that left you an opportunity.
- feralmoan 14y agoIt's not always "that obvious", some ideas just make sense for the time, and there are some seriously low-grade patents filed which barely even qualify as invention anyway. I'd hate to be drawn into some BS politicking at the sake of concentrating on my technology. Look at Leibniz&Newton ... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leibniz%E2%80%93Newton_calculus_controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leibniz%E2%80%93Newton_calculus...
- Nursie 14y agohttp://xkcd.com/626/ http://xkcd.com/626/
- mikeash 14y agoHow is "just make sense for the time" different from "that obvious"?
- feralmoan 14y agoI read the implication 'that obvious' by the OP as being obviously in cahoots or as obvious derivative works, rather than independent works along the same line of enquiry and execution.
- mikeash 14y agoOh, I thought he meant that the invention itself was obvious, i.e. unpatentable because anyone knowledgeable in the field in question would come up with that solution when presented with that problem. In theory, "obvious" inventions aren't patentable, although in practice the bar is set pretty low.
- Nursie 14y agoOh right, no. By 'obvious' I meant that if two people come up with the same thing independently then maybe the thing they came up with is comparatively not that special or innovative, and that perhaps if you have multiple folks in a field coming up with the same ideas then those ideas are not the ones deserving of protection. --edit-- this would be because patents (in my mind) are the exchange of protection/exclusivity from the state in return for disclosure to the commons of an idea that might never otherwise become known or publicised. If loads of folks are coming up with the same idea and racing to patent it, that points (to me) to a situation that patents aren't meant to address - giving exclusivity to someone based simply on them being first of many. If many can come up with it, then the deal is lopsided and the exclusivity shouldn't be granted. IMHO.