4 ms·
They don't mention my favorite idea: move the Earth. (I first saw a tiny blurb about this idea in a magazine, then saw it mentioned as an idea Russian scientist
by gojomo 18y ago
They don't mention my favorite idea: move the Earth. (I first saw a tiny blurb about this idea in a magazine, then saw it mentioned as an idea Russian scientists had considered.)
Apparently if you detonate a nuke on the moon, it will eject some of the moon's mass. The resulting change to the Earth-moon system alters the Earth's orbit around the sun ever-so-slightly.
However, 'ever-so-slightly' totaled over months or years means the Earth is thousands of miles from where it would have been otherwise, converting a direct-hit into a near-miss (or vice-versa!).
With enough warning, this could be a preferable approach, because it's assembled from things we already know how to do (like reach the moon), rather than targeting some tiny object at an extreme distance (an all-new challenge).
- cglee 18y agoHave you seen "Time Machine"? There's a scenario where a moon-based mining project goes awry, causing moon fragments to fall to Earth and basically destroying all advanced civilizations. I didn't think that was remotely possible, but maybe it is. Would love to see the article you mentioned.
- gojomo 18y agoSadly, a bunch of Googling and Yahooing hasn't turned up a reference. I'd seen the first blurb in print possibly as far back as the late 80s/early 90s, perhaps in 'Chemical and Engineering News'. (Their online archives only go back to 1998.) The later followup that suggested Soviets had done similar calculations might have been early-to-mid 90s, might have been online... but unsure. Yes, the moon-mining disaster in 2002's 'Time Machine' was pretty cool. The Orlando Bloom computer that still works 800K years in the future was more far-fetched than the moon collapsing, though. Turns out both the US and USSR considered demonstration nuclear explosions on the moon before thinking better of it: The US: http://partners.nytimes.com/library/national/science/051600sci-us-nuke.html?st=cse&sq=nuke+moon+sagan&scp=1 http://partners.nytimes.com/library/national/science/051600s... The USSR: http://www.svengrahn.pp.se/histind/E3/E3orig.htm http://www.svengrahn.pp.se/histind/E3/E3orig.htm And more recently, scientists have suggested a series of other-body-flybys could move the Earth to a further orbit: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/1154784.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/1154784.stm
- endtime 18y agoWhy is that your favorite idea? It sounds like the most potentially harmful to us, long-term, by far. I'm no ecologist but I have to imagine changing our orbit could screw up the balance of our ecosystems pretty badly.
- gojomo 18y agoIt's my favorite because it's unique, plausible, and thought-provoking -- not just 'blow up or deflect the asteroid' (as just about every other idea is). The essence of the idea was that it only takes a tiny, tiny change for the Earth to wind up far away from the collision location, though not necessarily any different in its average orbit. So climate/ecosystems wouldn't necessarily be affected. But now that you mention it, the second mention of the idea I saw -- ejecting moon mass to subtly change the Earth's orbit -- may have been in the context of intentional climate engineering rather than asteroid defense.