3 ms·
Ask HN: Murder trial iPhone forensics
For no reason other than interest this power log theory sounds dodgy to me.
http://brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/badenclay-charged-phone-after-time-he-claimed-to-be-asleep-court-20130312-2fxe4.html
Do any iPhone forensics/Developers have opinions? The face time bit seems to me they just kept going until they found anything they wanted, then stopped rather than thinking about whether it was actually useful / true.
They have done a similar thing before http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/sinister-motive-for-taking-the-fifth-challenged-20121217-2bj9y.html
Australians all know the 5th is an American idea so it was strange concept to begin with.
Where the case is, is in Australias north, being a southern hemisphere country that makes it kinda like Americas south so you can get the picture on the policing in the area.
Anyway I thought it was interesting and it smells a bit funny to me. Just wondering what others thought.
- anigbrowl 14y agoSeems OK to me. I don't have an iPhone myself, but I do have an app on my phone that tracks battery usage, and it would be easy to enough to test the accuracy of the charging log on the defendant's iPhone - copy the existing data, then plug and unplug it at random intervals, recording the time from some external source while doing so, and see if the stored log provides an accurate reflection of that record. Of course you'd also need to test the reliability of the defendant's charger and the integrity of the wall socket it was plugged into, but it's up to defense counsel to raise those questions. It doesn't appear from this report that the defendant has claimed the phone's charging was an unreliable, hit-and-miss affair, as might result from a damaged connector or somesuch. ‘There was a false positive in the tests,’ Mr Roberston, of the Queensland Police Service’s Electronic Evidence Examination Unit, said. Mr Robertson’s initial analysis found records of a FaceTime call on Mr Baden-Clay’s iPhone 3GS about 12.30am on April 20. ‘An iPhone 3GS isn’t capable of making FaceTime calls,’ Mr Robertson said. ‘So the whole thing is just wrong,’ Mr Davis said. This is called a fallacy of composition - because one aspect of the forensic report was erroneous, it must all be false. Errors like this are certainly an argument for heightened scrutiny of other claims from the same source on probabilistic grounds, but they don't logically invalidate parallel claims (whereas they would invalidate claims made pursuant to the non-existent Facetime call, such as a claim about the recipient or duration of said call). The mistake might be nothing more than a clerical error, such as inaccurately referring to a series of text messages as a Facetime call. Such mistakes should certainly be pointed out as such and the overall reliability of the forensic analysis questioned, but the mere existence of errors in the prosecution case does not invalidate the case as a whole. A miscarriage of justice would only occur where a conviction rested solely upon erroneous evidence. Often you hear people challenging their convictions by correctly pointing out flaws in the prosecution case that were not discovered at trial, but you have a keep a sense of perspective. Suppose the prosecution says A stabbed B and was taken into custody dressed in a blood-drenched green t-shirt. Defendant argues that he never owned a green t-shirt. Years later the t-shirt in question ids covered at the bottom of a crate in a police evidence room, and what do you know, it's blue! definitely a mistake, the defendant was telling the truth. So he's innocent, right? Not necessarily; if he was caught in the act of plunging the knife into the victim and there's abundant other evidence of his guilt, then the screwup over the color of the t-shirt won't set him free. At most he'll be granted a retrial and the other evidence will be sufficient to convict him again.