3 ms·
I'm not sure how making the argument that blaming regulators who created the incentives and environment for an industry to act against their long term self inte
by cwan 18y ago
I'm not sure how making the argument that blaming regulators who created the incentives and environment for an industry to act against their long term self interest is inconsistent with being libertarian. What Wall Street did was celebrated by regulators and legislators up until the point they realized that it was a house of cards (which was after its collapse). Wall Street took the bait - for which I'm not going to deny they have some responsibility over their own destruction - and they have paid heavily financially for that pain (look at financial sector stock prices and how many actually remain), But to the original point (and the linked post):
"A free market in which participants risked their own money might work quite well, but that’s not what we tried. We had a market in which participants risked other peoples’ money and pocketed much of the upside but suffered no downside risk, all made possible by the government’s regulating away public company shareholder power."
AIG's demise has come rather late in the game. CDS's are responsible for their massive losses, however CDS's are not responsible for this crisis. There's a difference here. However what's infuriating about the response that it is overdone relative to the crisis. He wants to be able to monitor risks private firms take with their own money and that of their investors. This is a power grab - since it's not like he only wants these powers for AIG - for something akin to the rogue trading at Barings bank. AIG's collapse could have been managed. Most of the business units held by AIG are actually quite profitable not to mention highly regulated.
To put this in perspective with respect to legislation, what Geithner could have done if he wanted to have an orderly liquidation or even save AIG was to push for the suspension of mark-to-market which would have allowed AIG not to seek massive amounts of funding to meet _regulatory_ requirements. AIG was already regulated as an insurer and as a financial institutions. What Geithner wants extends far beyond preventing what happened to AIG.
- crux_ 18y ago> 'm not sure how making the argument that blaming regulators who created the incentives and environment for an industry to act against their long term self interest is inconsistent with being libertarian. Perhaps a metaphor will help you see the contradiction. Who do I blame for my eventual heart attack: The fast food industry, who has created the incentives and environment for my obesity, or my own damn shortsighted self? Depending on the degree of your libertarianism, you would answer "entirely yourself" or "you bear primary responsibility but the fast food industry certainly helped you on your way." To blame the fast food industry is rather counter to the entire principle of individual responsibility, yet this is exactly what you are doing when you blame regulators for Wall Street's 'heart attack.' The rest of your response is about "what should (not) be done," not "who should we blame" so I'll just leave it at that.