7 ms·
> Second, I think it's rather difficult to pin much blame on regulators. The two levers used that have made this so particularly awful, CDOs and CDSs, were almo
by anamax 18y ago
> Second, I think it's rather difficult to pin much blame on regulators. The two levers used that have made this so particularly awful, CDOs and CDSs, were almost entirely over-the-counter, unregulated affairs,
As has been pointed out repeatedly, that's wrong. (I note the absence of the other two legs, namely subprime, and the bank balance sheet concentration caused by tax policy wrt fannie and freddie stock, both of which are clearly regulator caused.)
Regulators approved all use of CDOs and CDSs by banks and insurance companies. We know that because those institutions get no benefit from holding unapproved assets. (Solvency is a measure of the relationship between regulated assets and liabilities.) In the case of insurance companies, there are additional restrictions on the other side - they can't write unapproved policies.
Every part of AIG is regulated, uusually by regulators from multiple nations and they do cooperate.
Yes, I know what the fed chairman said about AIG's London office. He was dead wrong about that, which is consistent with his record of predictions over the last two years.
- crux_ 18y agoWithout needing to dive into the details, I don't think it would change things a bit if "regulators" were offering free cocaine to anyone who asked for it: it would not somehow absolve the junkies of the responsibility for their choice to snort it up.
- anamax 18y agoThe difference is that banks are free to ignore free cocaine. They're not free to ignore regulators. It appears that much of AIG's financial insurance was actually regulator driven, as in regulators insisted that banks buy it. More to the point, regulation is being proposed as a solution. Since they're the common element in all of the failures, this is a curious approach.
- crux_ 18y ago> The difference is that banks are free to ignore free cocaine. They're not free to ignore regulators. Misdirection. The toxic, risky, highly over-leveraged speculation they engaged in was certainly voluntary.
- anamax 18y agoNot at all - you ignored the next sentence, so I'll repeat it: "It appears that much of AIG's financial insurance was actually regulator driven, as in regulators insisted that banks buy it."
- crux_ 18y agoAnother misdirection. I did not refer to AIG specifically as toxic, risky, or over-leveraged, but to many (the majority?) of Wall Street's recent decisions. Also, it is completely false. Banks only "needed" to buy bond insurance from AIG when they voluntarily chose to securitize + re-sell CDO tranches (for example), and I'm not an expert enough to know what the regulations say, but ratings agencies also insisted on it. Further, AIG was under no obligation whatsoever to sell CDS contracts; this was a fully voluntary activity!
- anamax 18y ago> Further, AIG was under no obligation whatsoever to sell CDS contracts; this was a fully voluntary activity! That's not how regulated industries work. If a regulator says "you should produce a {type of product}", you do so or pay a significant price. For example, Wells Fargo took a huge hit for years because it wasn't as aggressive wrt subprime mortages as other banks. It wasn't allowed to open branches, make acquisitions, and so on in situations where institutions that did "play ball" were given the green light. Assets are one of the key regulatory constraint on banks. By giving banks favorable asset and tax treatment for holding Fannie and Freddie stock, not to mention "you really need to support them" advice from regulators, banks who didn't hold far more fannie and freddie stock than would otherwise be justified took a huge hit. In short, it wasn't a "voluntary" choice.
- crux_ 18y agoI won't dispute that the regulatory environment encouraged or discouraged certain actions, but that is very different from forcing anything. I can encourage you to smoke (say, by subsidizing tobacco), but that's hardly the same as forcing you to do so. Secondly, CDS contracts or CDO securities certainly weren't mandated by regulators, nor is there even much evidence that they were encouraged; they were merely permitted. There is no way that you can argue that the companies who buried themselves in the things were forced to do so by regulators and maintain anything resembling credibility. My condolences on your ideology's incompatibility with reality.