7 ms·
I mean no offense, and I realize that this is your site; but I really think jug6ernaut's comment added far more value than your response. I don't think jug6ern
by cperciva 14y ago
I mean no offense, and I realize that this is your site; but I really think jug6ernaut's comment added far more value than your response.
I don't think jug6ernaut missed the point whatsoever, and I wouldn't characterize him as nit-picking either: The question of who is expected to understand the t-shirt and what its point is (as compared to an unbranded t-shirt) are perfectly reasonable. Personally I see nothing wrong with t-shirts which can only be understood by an "in" group, but that doesn't mean that there's anything wrong with asking if that was the intention.
Your reply, on the other hand, strikes me as exactly the sort of knee-jerk defensiveness which often makes me wish that submitters couldn't comment on their own posts: Not only did you fail to answer the question, but you implied that jug6ernaut was being unreasonable to even ask it.
It's your site and you're entitled to encourage and discourage whichever types of posts you want -- but I think if your desire is to have a site where people engage in meaningful discussion, you made a poor choice here.
- andrewguenther 14y agopg isn't saying that the comment misses the point, he is saying that the comment is saying that the post is missing the point. He wasn't saying the original comment was unreasonable at all. The original comment is the exact kind of thing you would see as top comment on this kind of post, and that isn't a bad thing.
- rednukleus 14y agoWhen I first read pg's comment I interpreted it the same way as cperciva. But after reading your comment, I'm not sure any more.
- fakeer 14y agoPlease read pg's next comment(above) and you might be sure again. I think he meant what cperciva interpreted. Here - "I want HN to be a site where people engage in meaningful discussion that I try to discourage people from upvoting the first dismissive comment they come across"
- rednukleus 14y agoAgreed, my first instinct was right.
- BHSPitMonkey 14y ago"It would be humorously appropriate if the top comment on the thread about the official HN t-shirt were the traditional nitpicking/point-missing type that is so commonly the top comment" I'm pretty sure he was talking about the comment...
- pg 14y agoI feel like I'm trapped in an HN parody. It's precisely because I want HN to be a site where people engage in meaningful discussion that I try to discourage people from upvoting the first dismissive comment they come across. Even discourage is probably too strong a word though. I feel like someone standing in the surf, trying to hold back a breaking wave with his hand. (I didn't answer his question because other users already had: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5363492 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5363492)
- hallowtech 14y agoMaybe you should allow downvoting for everyone then. I'm more likely to downvote a dismissive reply then I am to upvote every positive reply to overtake it. And on the mention of dismissive comments: as a frequent visitor I feel emotionally safer just reading and not posting... so if there is a karma threshold for allowing downvotes, I doubt I will ever hit it.
- ihuman 14y agoThe problem is that people would abuse the downvote button and use it as a representation of "I disagree with you" is read of "this comment adds no value to the conversation."
- jiggy2011 14y agoOr sign up shill accounts to repeatedly downvote people they don't like.
- cpeterso 14y agoDisallow both up and down vote buttons for the top comment. The top few comments will rise together, taking turns having vote buttons or not.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoEven with the current restrictions people still use it quite extensively as a "I disagree" button.
- whyleyc 14y agoIt's a t-shirt. It's raising money for a great cause. Buy it if you like it. If not, spare us the semantic analysis - the only thing it does is add to the perception of a community disappearing up it's own arse.
- hawkharris 14y agoI agree with you and jug6ernaut. I love the concept of the shirt, and, at the same time, I think the design could be improved. There's nothing wrong with making polite, constructive suggestions, as you both did.