5 ms·
It's well known that Canonical likes to do things their way and maybe suffers from a slight NIH syndrome. But do people have to be so upset about it? Maybe Roge
by bjourne 14y ago
It's well known that Canonical likes to do things their way and maybe suffers from a slight NIH syndrome. But do people have to be so upset about it? Maybe Rogers explanation is completely wrong and the real reason is "we thought it would be fun to write a new display server!" Does it matter? Saying "you're increasing desktop fragmentation" is silly and implies that writing Mir is somehow worse than writing no code at all.
Graphics on desktop Linux currently kind of sucks. Windows and OS X are years ahead while we are stuck on X11 with flakey, sometimes-working, compiz-quality 3d effects. I think any effort to remedy that situation should be cherised.
- vidarh 14y agoI think it boils down to people being upset because Canonical through Ubuntu actually has the power to make Mir a real contender just like that, and it may very well leave Wayland in the dust due to internal discussions in Canonical rather than gaining acceptance by the community first Everything else seems like excuses to me. And while I use Ubuntu, and Mir sounds appealing, especially given my experience with other Ubuntu projects (including Unity, which I love), I don't particularly like this approach either. Though I have no reason to think I won't stick with Ubuntu.
- dscrd 14y ago>Saying "you're increasing desktop fragmentation" is silly and implies that writing Mir is somehow worse than writing no code at all. Nope. The logical option to writing Mir is not "no code at all" but contributing code and influence to supporting Wayland.
- fingerprinter 14y agoWhy? What if Wayland and Mir have different goals? What if the venn-diagram overlap of those goals is less than ideal for Ubuntu and where it is going? Look at the absolute MESS that compiz, x and other things in Linux have had b/c of the "support all the things" attitude. The simple FACT is that it is much easier to be exceedingly great at a small subset of things than a large super set of things. Mir is specific and exact to what Canonical wants and needs out of Ubuntu. Wayland is a GENERAL solution that, sure, Canonical could influence, but would ultimately need to be more than just what Canonical needs. That means, you guessed it, bugs, rough corners, things that aren't supported. It's called focus. Canonical is focusing on delivering an EXPERIENCE and they decided they could do it better in this approach. I agree with this b/c of 1. history 2. experience and 3. the current state of the various projects. And don't forget that the code is going to be open source. And I don't understand why this is a problem in the linux world when the web world this is typically encouraged as "the best project will win". Do we need Derby, Backbone, Meteor, Tower, Express, Knockout etc etc etc? What about Rails, Sinatra, Camping, Padrino? Django, Flask, Pyramid? Riak,Mongo,Couch? Why can't they all join forces and "contribute code and influence"? In the web world, this is kind of encouraged and seen as good for competition. In the linux world is it seen as "not being a good community member". It's fuckin' bullshit.
- Nursie 14y ago"Windows and OS X are years ahead" Really? How? Not sure I've seen it, but then I haven't used OSX since snow-leopard. Genuinely interested in what you think I might be missing out on.
- FooBarWidget 14y agoOn OS X, things generally just work, and work quickly. 3D performance is good. I've never had graphics hardware that was not supported. Granted, OS X doesn't have to deal with a lot of different hardware configurations like Linux does, but still. On Linux, things are flaky. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. Some things work, other things do not. Alt-Tab out of full screen games? Upgrading the NVIDIA and ATI graphics driver without dropping out of X? Not possible. 3D performance is extremely variable: depending on your driver and hardware, some 3D operations are hardware accelerated, others are not. On OS X everything that should be hardware accelerated, always is. Ditto on Windows. The Windows Display Driver Model allows upgrading the display driver without rebooting, and without even relogging in. It runs the display driver partially in user mode so that if it crashes it can be restarted. I don't know how far Linux is away from a similar feat.
- Nursie 14y agoI was kinda meaning user-experience stuff, rather than the quality of the backend. What do the OSX or Windows desktops do with the 3D capability, in terms of improved experience or workflow, that Linux doesn't? I'm not really a gamer any more so I don't often run into any issues with full-screen gaming. I'm pretty sure that the video driver on linux can be updated without a reboot, but you'd probably need to log out of X, yes.
- bjourne 14y agoJust read up on why Wayland was created and what problems it indents to correct. Im not interested in enumerating X11:s latency issues, compositing and font rendering limitations etc when someone has already done the job much better than me. You may also try and use a recent Windows version for a few days and see if you can spot the differences.
- mtgx 14y agoAs a non-Linux user, it's funny to me how Linux users complain about how this will bring fragmentation to Linux, when Linux is one of the most fragmented ecosystems ever. There are tens or hundred of different distros, and at least several different application packages, and I'm probably not aware about a lot of other stuff, too. I support Canonical in this move, because they do need a very optimized display server and interface for mobile hardware, and they are also the ones who've pushed Linux the most into the mainstream, sometimes by taking steps that are very annoying to regular Linux users, but in the same time very pragmatic in bringing Linux closer to the non-technical current Linux user, or future Linux user.
- shmerl 14y agoFragmentation can be very different. The sickest type of it is hardware fragmentation caused by incompatible drivers. The most obvious example is Android. Their choice of bionic libc makes running normal glibc Linux with Android drivers impossible (unless you attempt to translate glibc into bionic, like libhybris does). So this fragmentation creates a very strong barrier for using hardware and everyone would agree such kind of rifts are not a pleasant thing. Luckily in Mir's case Canonical seems to be interested in avoiding drivers fragmentation with Wayland.
- fluidcruft 14y agoWhy is Android the bad actor for people writing non-portable software that relies on non-standard GNU extensions?
- shmerl 14y agoI didn't understand the question. libc lies in the core of the system, and if libc is incompatible it translates to non reusable drivers, which translates to "Android only" hardware. What do you call a "non-standard GNU extension"?
- Ziomislaw 14y agono sane person would want to use glibc EVER!
- Symmetry 14y agoAs far as it actually goes it's only a missed opportunity for collaboration, but if Mir and Wayland end up being less compatible than Ubuntu is promising it could also mean a lot of extra effort for others. Specifically, if they don't end up being able to use the same desktop drivers then this schism will cause a lot of extra work for driver writers. And if applications can't simply link against the Ubuntu-provided Mir version of libwayland then that'll be a lot of extra work for application writers.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoWhoa there. Yes, X sucks for a huge number of reasons, but please don't assume that all existing compositors are as buggy as compiz. Mutter and KWin work quite well.
- fingerprinter 14y agoMutter works...now. Ubuntu used mutter at one point and it was TERRIBLE. Performance, crashes and the lot. I recall they tried to improve it and got massive pushback from GNOME. This led them to use Compiz, which had its own issues. I can totally see why they would do something like Mir given the history of non-supportiveness they got from the various upstream projects in the past.
- drivebyacct2 14y ago/shrug I don't have a problem with Mir, mostly just the way it was announced by dumping on Wayland. Frankly, with Canonical working closely with Nvidia on an EGL driver that Wayland could also use... I see a net win for everyone when the dust settles. It's funny, anyone remember Beryl? Compiz-fusion? :) Fun times in OSS land.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]