3 ms·
You're ignoring the social and governmental factors. Technological improvement actually did lead to widespread unemployment once: the Great Depression. There
by eli_gottlieb 14y ago
You're ignoring the social and governmental factors.
Technological improvement actually did lead to widespread unemployment once: the Great Depression. There was simply no need for so much farm labor after it turned out that unlimited and leveraged stock-market investment wouldn't make returns on every last penny and bushel.
(Everyone in those days, no matter their political slant, knew what overproduction was.)
The eventual solution was to raise wages, shorten working hours, allow unionization and go to war. I'm only partially joking.
On some level, widespread technological unemployment is a sign that our productivity is too high for our designated amount of work that constitutes a "real job" or "full time".
http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/ http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/
- eurleif 14y agoBut it's more efficient to hire 1 worker for 8 hours than 2 workers for 4 hours. The latter has more overhead in terms of training, etc. Why would an employer choose to do that?
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoBy the same token, it's more efficient to hire one worker for 16 hours than two workers for 8 hours. Why do employers do that? (Also, the fixed-costs of hiring workers can be somewhat decreased through various means. For example, if you're in the United States, the American employer-sponsored insurance system is so appallingly inefficient that it's obvious low-hanging fruit for reduction of fixed costs. Get rid of it and go universal!)
- eurleif 14y ago>By the same token, it's more efficient to hire one worker for 16 hours than two workers for 8 hours. Not necessarily. Being tired reduces efficiency.
- minimax 14y ago"Technological improvement actually did lead to widespread unemployment once: the Great Depression." Economists argue about the causes of the Great Depression, but the idea that the Great Depression was caused by improvements in technology is not one I've ever heard.
- loup-vaillant 14y agoIf I recall correctly, Einstein himself said it. (I know, wrong area of expertise. But he is famous.) And now, productivity (as measured by the GDP per employee —I know it's a flawed measure) literally shot through the roof since the 1970s. When production rises for whatever reason, either demand rises with it or we eventually have unemployment. I understand you never heard the argument, but why would production rise? I only see two reason: population growth (no problem, demand will rise as well), and technological advancement. Now, technology also increase demand. We all want more modern gadgets and all. But it is not clear this growth in demand outpaces the growth in production.