4 ms·
Obama Administration supports journalist who was arrested after recording cops
- tptacek 14y agoThe Holder DOJ has been sending notices to state AG's and LEO's informing them that laws restricting the recording of police officers are unconstitutional. Good for them. I'm not sure what this has to do with HN, though, so I flagged it. Sorry, Bill! :|
- dkkkdkdk 14y agoBad bad tptacek. I'm surprised by your comment. Initially I though, this guy has to be a newbie, we discuss this kinds of things all the time here, which is one of the main reasons I come to this place. Hacker News is notorious for loving this kind of stuff so I'm not so sure why something like this is not relevant. Specially since Obama and Holder have many times not been on the same side as us. i.e. copyright, Is kind of surprising to see them protecting civil liberties when lately I've felt they have not been doing a very good job.
- tptacek 14y agoYou can't even argue for this story being germane without trying to start a political argument, which I'm going to call case- in- point. I unflagged, and then flagged again.
- dkkkdkdk 14y ago>> You can't even argue for this story being germane without trying to start a political argument Which is fine in my view. Is a lot of fun to read the political points and counter-points of a lot of people. You really learn a lot. edit: I guess you could say this is not the right forum to discuss politics. Not all the time, maybe. Some of the time I think is fine since politics affects all of us. Unfortunately, right now there is no better place to have intelligent discussion in all types of topics so I do enjoy it when we analyze stories like this. We need to have a diverse diet, I believe.
- tptacek 14y agoI suspect you haven't read the site guidelines yet.
- alexqgb 14y agoUh, if you're going to cite the guidelines, please make sure you're not opening the comment thread by violating them. Specifically: "Please don't submit comments complaining that a submission is inappropriate for the site. If you think something is spam or offtopic, flag it by going to its page and clicking on the "flag" link. (Not all users will see this; there is a karma threshold.) If you flag something, please don't also comment that you did." More to the point, the story wasn't about politics per se (at least not about partisan disagreement). It was about a policy shift (not the same thing) that can have real implications for technology (i.e. Glass, which could be technically illegal in jurisdictions that have misapplied wiretapping laws to limit counter-survailence of the police). More amusingly, this is a story about over-agressive policing and the push-back it's attracted. You respond with over-agressive policing and get angry with push-back it attracts. See the irony?
- tptacek 14y agoNo, I do not see the irony. Posting on HN isn't a constitutionally protected civil liberty.
- alexqgb 14y agoAs Lessig (among others) has noted, "code is law", which makes politics and technology inseparable (case in point: PIPA/SOPA). What worries me are technologists who not only don't understand this, but think it's appropriate to "flag" discussion about this reality. Seriously, this is like creationists sticking fingers in ears and saying "lalalalala" every time someone whispers "Darwin."
- tptacek 14y agoOh, look, we managed to work creationism into the thread! And this is what happens when the Obama administration does something good.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 14y agoHN user says "story not germane, flagged". Another HN users say: "you're a useful idiot". Definitely, let's have more stories like this on HN. We're not getting the full gamut of namecalling by limiting ourselves to language and editor wars; there's no "fifth column of vi supporters".
- alexqgb 14y agoHere's Evgany Morozov with a more thoughtful account of the cognitive limits revealed by the parent comment, which are functions of inadequate education, rather than deficits of intelligence or good-will. Expressing this in an insulting way is obviously unhelpful, but avoiding discussion of very real blind spots is worse. "We don't treat them (Google et. al.) with the level of criticism and scrutiny that they deserve, we assume they are in the business of information which is a benign business and they are part of the enlightenment project. We tend not to think they have shareholders, commercial agendas and are run by people who might not have a very deep appreciation of the human condition and the world around us. I have a lot of respect for these people as engineers but they are being asked to take on tasks that go far beyond engineering. Tasks that have to do with human and social engineering rather than technical engineering. Those are the kind of tasks I would prefer were taken on by human beings who are more well rounded, who know about philosophy and ethics, and know something about things other than efficiency, because it will not end well." Full interview here: http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2013/mar/09/evgeny-morozov-technology-solutionism-interview http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2013/mar/09/evgeny-moro...
- tptacek 14y agoAny story that leads a stranger on HN to tell another stranger on HN that they lack understanding of philosophy and ethics after less than ~100 words of commentary is a bad story for HN.
- drucken 14y agoI'm not sure what this has to do with HN, though, so I flagged it. Sorry, Bill! :| HN Guidelines: "Please don't submit comments complaining that a submission is inappropriate for the site. If you think something is spam or offtopic, flag it by going to its page and clicking on the "flag" link. (Not all users will see this; there is a karma threshold.) If you flag something, please don't also comment that you did." Regardless of whether you're right or wrong, for an old hand, tptacek, not impressed...
- tptacek 14y agoI am prepared to sacrifice 1000 karma points for every comment I write saying I flagged a story. Please feel free to petition Paul Graham to make that happen.
- wglb 14y agoI can see your point, but I have seen useful discussions about what is legal to do with technology in this particular public space, so we disagree a bit on this. Whenever I hear of the police reaction to being recorded, I find myself wondering if they are thinking of Rodney King. Keep in mind that the whole Rodney King thing would not have happened without a video recorder. I find the discussion on this topic interesting--law and technology, but I can see why many might not.
- chris_mahan 14y agoI would suggest that if the White House was really concerned that these police officers had violated the Constitution, that the President should order the National Guards to arrest the officers involved (including their supervisors all the way to the chief of police for failure to properly supervise) and deliver them to a Federal Grand Jury and charge them with sedition against the United States. Then other police officers around the country would think twice before violating the law. Right now they're just washing their hands of their responsibility and essentially saying that the US constitution is not law.
- tptacek 14y agoProblem: Civil liberties concerns. Solution: Re-introduce enforcement of seditious conspiracy statutes. This is creative legal problem solving a caliber only found on HN political threads.
- mpyne 14y ago> I would suggest that if the White House was really concerned that these police officers had violated the Constitution, that the President should order the National Guards to arrest the officers involved (including their supervisors all the way to the chief of police for failure to properly supervise) and deliver them to a Federal Grand Jury and charge them with sedition against the United States. You cannot possibly be serious. The President is supposed to mobilize military assets and compel a grand jury to issue his chosen indictment? You're completely missing the forest for the trees here, not to mention knowledge of the Posse Comitatus Act.
- chris_mahan 14y agoSo then who is supposed to enforce violations of the constitution?
- mpyne 14y agoThe courts. Failing that, the people. How lame would it be to attempt to uphold the Constitution by blatantly breaching it?