3 ms·
That's not the power the President is claiming. It's much narrower than that. The President has not stated what limits there are to his power. He has stated l
by btilly 14y ago
That's not the power the President is claiming. It's much narrower than that.
The President has not stated what limits there are to his power. He has stated limits to what he will authorize. However if we accept that he can authorize it without having laid out limits to his authority, what stops another president from authorizing more?
Bear in mind, one of the most common ways for a democracy to become a dictatorship is for there to be broad emergency powers granted to the president - and then for the president to declare what effectively becomes a permanent state of emergency. Lest this seem paranoid, remember that the American experiment is 237 years old. If we assume that we are in a random point in time in the history of the USA, there is an a priori over a 10% chance that the USA will no longer exist in 24 years. There is a similar chance that the USA will survive another 2370 years. When we look across how long different types of government have lasted in different countries, the prospect of our system of government ending inside of 24 years is much more likely than its lasting 2370 years.
Does that seem absurd? I remember what the country was like 24 years ago. If you described what the USA would be like today to me back then, I'd have called it a dystopian fantasy. Democracy is more fragile than we want to believe. I'd like to keep it longer. And yes, I'm very willing to accept more trouble preventing terrorism if that is the cost. (And I'd also like to stop having to take my shoes off to get on an airplane...)