3 ms·
The article should stand (or not) on its merits, regardless of the journal of publication (or other medium) Of course I trust Nature more than, let's say "Bob'
by raverbashing 14y ago
The article should stand (or not) on its merits, regardless of the journal of publication (or other medium)
Of course I trust Nature more than, let's say "Bob's Journal about science stuff"
But sometimes even articles in Nature have been printed elsewhere first, (like a 'beta test' for the article - peer review nevertheless), usually in journals specific from the field (clarification below)
The "Identifying reliable sources" page is a Wikipedia policy, it has some good insights, but it is biased towards Wikipedia, see for example "Articles should rely on secondary sources whenever possible. For example, a review article, monograph, or textbook is better than a primary research paper"
Edit: Yes, journals usually don't accept content published elsewhere, my bad.
What happens is that, yes, you can't republish something 100% equal to something published elsewhere. (eg: http://www.ieee.org/documents/top10faq.pdf http://www.ieee.org/documents/top10faq.pdf ) but while the research progresses you provide more detailed papers or focus on different areas of research
- carbocation 14y ago> But sometimes even articles in Nature have been printed elsewhere first, (like a 'beta test' for the article - peer review nevertheless), usually in journals specific from the field. Not true. Republishing already-published work is specifically disallowed by Nature and most high impact journals. Doing so merits a retraction.