10 ms·
Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments
- aneth4 14y agoCould they not carbon date the fossils to see if they correspond with the existence of similar lifeforms on Earth?
- heidar 14y agoI do not think this would work on organisms that did not live and die in our atmosphere because the ratio of C12 and C14 is local to our atmosphere and might be very different where they come from.
- egeozcan 14y agothat apparently wouldn't work on extra-terrestrial stuff as it seems to depend on "the ratio of 14C to 12C in the atmosphere" and works for "up to about 58,000 to 62,000 years"[1] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiocarbon_dating http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiocarbon_dating
- aneth4 14y agoRight, so if it turned out to come from the future or 10 billion years ago on that scale, then it's likely extraterrestrial. As you say though, it's not good in the billions.
- schiffern 14y agoYou're not getting it. You can't date anything non-biological using carbon dating. It's not that you get the wrong answer. You get no answer, since you don't know a-priori what the ratio of C12 to C14 was when the sample was formed. The equations are under-constrained. You can still use radiological dating with other elements (e.g. Uranium). >if it turned out to come from the future I don't even…
- aneth4 14y agoDifficult to get what was not said in the comment I'm replying to. So fine, I don't know my dating techniques. Uranium radiological dating sounds fine. Why not that? >> if it turned out to come from the future > I don't even… have a sense of humor? It is certainly possible if we had a extra-terrestrial organic matter (which we don't) that it could test as coming from the future based on carbon ratios, though obviously it would not actually be from the future - thus "on that scale". I'm not sure if the same applies to Uranium radiological dating.
- tripzilch 14y agoBut we don't know future carbon ratios.
- evilduck 14y agoCarbon dating is only good for about 50,000 years back. There are other radiometric dating methods, but none as useful for dating lifeforms.
- wtvanhest 14y agoIts probably worth reading the last two paragraphs first: "There are other explanations, of course. One is that the fireball was of terrestrial origin, a remnant of one of the many asteroid impacts in Earth’s history that that have ejected billions of tonnes of rock and water into space, presumably with biological material inside. Another is that the structures are not biological and have a different explanation. Either way, considerably more work will have to be done before the claims from this team can be broadly accepted. Exciting times ahead!"
- carbocation 14y agoThe identified structures look no more nor less "lifelike" than other random bits found in the rock (image is here [1]). As far as I can tell, this evidence doesn't even begin to scratch at the surface of information needed to demonstrate or even really suggest that these were ever living organisms. The nail in the coffin, for me, is the fact that this is set to be published in the Journal of Cosmology, a publication of questionable repute [2]. [1] https://www.technologyreview.com/sites/default/files/images/Polonnaruwa%20meteorite.png https://www.technologyreview.com/sites/default/files/images/... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journal_of_Cosmology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journal_of_Cosmology
- raverbashing 14y ago"The nail in the coffin, for me, is the fact that this is set to be published in the Journal of Cosmology, a publication of questionable repute [2]." So it's ok to go Ad Hominem against anything that contradicts our current knowledge? Ok, got it
- carbocation 14y ago> So it's ok to go Ad Hominem against anything that contradicts our current knowledge? Ok, got it The whole point of scientific journals is to change our current knowledge, so that's not really a fair criticism of my dismissal. Read even just the Wikipedia article and you'll see that this journal has several issues: (1) the quality of its peer review is questionable; (2) it appears to promote fringe views; (3) it has been widely criticized by the scientific community. So yes, after criticizing the research itself, I also dug around and discovered problems with the journal it was being published in. I don't see anything wrong with doing so. Had the data looked less bogus I probably wouldn't have been suspicious enough to investigate the source.
- raverbashing 14y ago"So yes, after criticizing the research itself" Your point was that these features look as similar as other features and hence they should be the same. Now, the given article really reads like a press release more than anything, but I don't remember if the original article had something else on the picture. What I would think is that (but I am not sure) since these are electron microscope pictures, you can get a composition analysis of the sample from the microscope, hence being able to differentiate the features. And no, I'm not taking this research too seriously as well, I just find it funny that some people jump at it and seem to dismiss it at first sight.
- tokenadult 14y ago"This is an idea put forward by Fred Hoyle and Chandra Wickramasinghe, the latter being a member of the team who has carried out this analysis." Chandra Wickramasinghe is currently the MAIN guy promoting the idea discussed in the article kindly submitted here (as Hoyle has died). Hacker News participants can gain perspective on this idea by reading "Diatoms…iiiiin spaaaaaaaaaaace!" http://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2013/01/16/diatomsiiiiin-spaaaaaaaaaaace/ http://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2013/01/16/diatomsiii... and "Chandra Wickramasinghe replies…and fails hard" http://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2013/01/18/chandra-wickramasinghe-repliesand-fails-hard/ http://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2013/01/18/chandra-wi... to see comments by a biologist on why the evidence here is completely inadequate for Wickramasinghe's latest claim. Wickramasinghe has been around the block with claims like this before, and he is the editor of the main "journal" that promotes this idea, but none of his specific claims of finding extraterrestrial life have ever been backed up by convincing evidence. EDIT: I should add the link to a critique of the extraordinary claim here by an astronomer http://www.slate.com/blogs/bad_astronomy/2013/01/15/life_in_a_meteorite_claims_by_n_c_wickramasinghe_of_diatoms_in_a_meteorite.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/bad_astronomy/2013/01/15/life_in_... (this was linked in the links I put in this comment earlier), so you can see his comments on the new claim directly.
- nemo 14y agoWhile there seem to be serious issues with the research, it's hard to be won over by an article that starts with "You all know that the Journal of Cosmology is complete crap, right? In addition to some of the worst web design ever — it looks like a drunk clown puked up his fruit loops onto a grid of 1990s-style tables — the content is ridiculous, predictable, and credulous," and continues with "That’s the kind of rigorous scientific thinking we’re dealing with here." Admittedly I've never liked Myers style since he always has seemed to be an obnoxious advocate of a certain brand of orthodoxy, rather than giving any sense of nuanced or rigorous (scientific or otherwise) thinking.
- tripzilch 14y agoEspecially since I know many solid scientific websites with horrible design (especially professors' personal sites), so it's almost a show of ignorance to try and connect "rigorous scientific thinking" with proper web design.
- martinced 14y agoIt seems questionable but... Even if it was true, couldn't it have been organisms from earth ejected into orbit after a meteor strike and, thousands of years later or more, falling back to earth? Now if we find a definitive proof of panspermia it would be the biggest discovery ever made by mankind so far...
- schiffern 14y ago>couldn't it have been organisms from earth ejected into orbit after a meteor strike and, thousands of years later or more, falling back to earth? That would still be a hugely significant result. We expect a higher density of biologically contaminated samples near the Earth. This is perfectly compatible with (but does not prove) panspermia. The key question isn't whether space is sterile, but whether space is aseptic. That's harder to demonstrate. To illustrate the difference, imagine a doctor scrubbing for surgery. It's impossible to scrub your hands until there's a population of zero pathogens, but fortunately that is unnecessary. You just need to reduce the population enough that the few organisms that remain just can't get a foot-hold. We're in the back waters of the galaxy in a mature star system. Even if panspermia were rampant in the galaxy, we probably wouldn't see it. Stellar clusters, nebulae, Bok globules, and young star systems are where you would expect this kind of action. Mechanically speaking panspemia is just diffusion, except instead of Brownian motion you have impact ejecta and gravitational evaporation. Each of these events has a probability curve. You could even construct your own "Panspermia Drake Equation", something like: P = N_seed * R_ejection * Pop_specific * f_survival_ejection * f_escape * 2^-(T_encounter / t_1/2_cruise) * f_habitable * f_survival_reentry * f_germination P = rate of panspermia in a given volume of space N_seed = number of seed (life-bearing) bodies in that volume R_ejection = average rate at which mass is ejected from each seed body (kg/yr) Pop_specific = average specific population ('von Neumann' individuals/kg) of ejected material f_survive_ejection = fraction of population that survives ejection f_escape = fraction of ejected material that eventually escapes from the stellar system, either due to initial velocity or long-term orbital perturbations T_encounter = average length of time before an escaped object encounters another body t_1/2_cruise = half-life of population exposed to interstellar conditions f_habitable = fraction of encountered bodies that are habitable f_survive_reentry = fraction of population that survives reentry f_germination = fraction of the population that actually germinates Looking at this equation it's not hard to see why dense regions with young star systems are preferred. Young systems have higher ejection and escape rates. Survival rates for ejection and re-entry are a function of energy, so having many less massive bodies is preferred. Young, single-cell-only ecosystems increase the specific population. Of course, The number of seed bodies (N_seed) is the interesting part. This allows the equation to feed back on itself. Waaaaaaay out here in the Solar neighborhood, everything's so far apart that T_encounter rate limits that feedback to effectively zero, but in stellar clusters and nebulae you can find regions with dozens of stars per cubic light-year. As stars move within the galaxy they might experience different rates of panspermia – perhaps long lifeless intervals punctuated by "bursts" of bombardment, or maybe just once (in the conditions of the stellar nursery) and then never again. When it comes to panspermia as an origin theory (aka exogenesis) I consider myself a "weak atheist", if you will. The meager evidence we have seems to suggest that life on Earth originated in abiogenesis, not panspermia. That doesn't mean that panspermia does not occur.
- lifeisstillgood 14y ago"Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence" - Carl Sagan When you find a fossilised rabbit in the meteorite, call me.
- jmillikin 14y agoPreviously: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5055227 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5055227 General HN comment consensus is that the article is terribly poor science, published in a crank journal.
- gus_massa 14y agoNote: It was about a different analysis of the same event, by almost the same authors.
- Jabbles 14y agoThis has come up before. Although this paper is considerably better presented than the previous one, the conclusions are still the same - the author is biased and the evidence is weak. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5055227 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5055227 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5055547 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5055547
- systematical 14y agoI wouldn't call this clear evidence. Is it not possible the a large asteroid struck earth, kicking up debri from earth which happened to contain micro organisms. These organisms then died and fossilized in the space later returning...
- tripzilch 14y agoWhy does it always have to be Cardiff that gets all the aliens?
- easymovet 14y agoTheir city is built on a rift in the time space continuom. The energy it gives off can be harnessed to recharge the TARDIS.
- qwertzlcoatl 14y agoLet's all keep in mind that this paper was published by physicists, in non-peer reviewed journals. There is a lot of jumping the gun in these articles, especially when it's the lead authors first and only paper. Here is a link to the actual paper: http://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1303/1303.1845.pdf http://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1303/1303.1845.pdf Here is a slate article that has already proven that the data mined by the "Astrobiologists" is faulty and biased: http://www.slate.com/blogs/bad_astronomy/2013/01/15/life_in_a_meteorite_claims_by_n_c_wickramasinghe_of_diatoms_in_a_meteorite.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/bad_astronomy/2013/01/15/life_in_...
- celerity 14y agoPlease, please stop voting pseudo-science up so much. Look at the comments in the post. The second one pretty much explains why this "paper" has no credibility what-so-ever.
- drcube 14y agoBeen there, done that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allan_Hills_84001 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allan_Hills_84001 From the wiki article: '[T]he scientific consensus is that "morphology alone cannot be used unambiguously as a tool for primitive life detection."' But let me know when they find a skeleton fossil in a meteorite.
- lutusp 14y agoThere are some serious problems with this claim: 1. "In total, Jamie Wallis at Cardiff University and a few buddies received 628 stone fragments collected from rice fields in the region. However, they were able to clearly identify only three as possible meteorites." In other words, the researchers weren't in on the collection activity, and may not possess the expertise to distinguish meteoritic material from ordinary earthly rocks (that determination is not easy). 2. "One stone, for example, had a density of less than 1 gram per cubic centimetre, less than all known carbonaceous meteorites." And it didn't occur to these people that it wasn't a meteorite? Low-density meteors don't normally get to the ground -- they are much more likely to vaporize in the atmosphere. A low-density sample like this is immediately suspect. Conclusion: Three identifications out of 628 samples, one of the three is not likely to be a real meteorite, terrestrial contamination cannot really be ruled out, and this work is neither refereed AFAIK nor published in a normal scientific journal. I call shenanigans. Reference: http://arxiv.org/abs/1303.1845 http://arxiv.org/abs/1303.1845
- drkmtr999 14y agoDebunked months ago. Shame, HN
- bobwaycott 14y agoWhy is this article receiving so many upvotes given the rather apparent consensus that it is overhyped and/or untrustworthy analysis presented in a disreputable journal?
- brass9 14y agoIt's curious the MIT article tries to downplay the role of Wickramasinghe behind this research finding. NC Wickramasinghe may be a brilliant scientist, but any news regarding possible extra-terrestrial life-form and his name appearing together instantly raises alarm bells all over the place. Wickramasinghe is the von Däniken of astrobiology.