4 ms·
The business case for IE is to hold back the progress of the web, so that it doesn't threaten Microsoft's main profit centers.
by ZeroGravitas 14y ago
The business case for IE is to hold back the progress of the web, so that it doesn't threaten Microsoft's main profit centers.
- chaz 14y agoHanlon's Razor applies here: "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity."
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoYou're telling me IE's devs were so stupid they couldn't add a spell-checker until IE10? Is that really more believable than internal corporate interests deciding that it threatened Word?
- chaz 14y agoStupidity isn't about the individual developers -- it's about the incompetent decisions that Microsoft made about the browser. They decided that IE would be released only in-sync with new Windows releases. Vista troubles meant IE was effectively on hiatus between 2001 (IE6) and 2006 (IE7). Corporate interests were definitely keeping IE development back, but not as an intentional defensive move to sabotage the Web. Lack of competition in browsers during that period served as a pretty good demotivator, too.
- ZeroGravitas 14y ago"One thing we have got to change in our strategy - allowing Office documents to be rendered very well by other peoples browsers is one of the most destructive things we could do to the company. We have to stop putting any effort into this and make sure that Office documents very well depends on PROPRIETARY IE capabilities." -- Bill Gates, 1998 a memo to the Office product group[2] Seems like the guy in charge knew when to actively "stop putting effort into" things and intentionally sabotage the open web when necessary. https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Bill_Gates https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Bill_Gates
- walid 14y agoIronically the reason I've tried my best to avoid MS Office is because they are not easily accessible by anyone. I once sent my CV as an HTML file along with a PDF. Still to this day, I prefer to send HTML and PDF over sending a Word document they only need an app that everybody uses, a browser.
- brudgers 14y agoWhat is more believable is that spell check in the browser is somewhat of an edge case relative to general browser usage (i.e. web consumption) which Microsoft was historically able to address by allowing plug-ins. They rolled it into the development of their plug-inless browser and rolled their plug-inless browser into their not quite so backward compatible OS release. I suspect that the corporate interests have long known that IE is not a sales critical feature.
- criley 14y agoYou're telling me that you actually believe that developers at Microsoft pick and choose what features they include in a browser? You can blame software designers at Microsoft for that decision (or lack of decision), but I'm fairly sure that dev's at Microsoft are on the "fulfill the design" side of developing...
- sc0rb 14y agoMaybe there's a data protection law in one American state that has nothing to do with the conversation that you would like to refer too? bubble.....
- criley 14y agoWhat you're doing is "cyber-stalking", following me across threads and insulting me because a conversation did not end up like you want. Please stop this immature behavior.
- milfot 14y agoJust because they are stupid, does not mean they are not malicious.. in my experience the two are common bedfellows. Though in this case I think maybe there is a third option.. ignorance maybe?
- chaz 14y agoAgreed. I usually use the version of Hanlon's Razor that substitutes "incompetence" for "stupidity." Not that they didn't understand what was at stake, but made a series of bad decisions.
- brudgers 14y agoThat is patent nonsense. The web grew because Windows users were able to browse it with IE in the days before Netscape and when the second choice was going with *nix and Mosaic. IE killed Gopher by taking browsing to the masses. Netscape was a startup and its founder had a Fuck You Money exit before it met its fate as a corporate subsidiary managed across a continent. The legacy of IE6 lives with us because of suboptimal architectural decisions by web developers. Yet, the web is escaping it - unlike the warts of JavaScript.
- ZeroGravitas 14y ago"IE in the days before Netscape"?
- brudgers 14y agoFrom a practical perspective, yes. IE bootstrapped access to Navigator for the general population of computer users. People got Navigator using IE to download it from Netscape's website - just like they get Chrome, Firefox, and Opera today. Until IE shipped with Windows, the only way a typical user was going to get Netscape was on a floppy disk via the shareware community or perhaps from a BBS. It wasn't being downloaded through AOL or Compuserve and if it was, what would one have done with it August 1995? It would be naive to ignore Netscape's IPO occurred one week before IE 1.0.
- justinschuh 14y ago>That is patent nonsense. The web grew because Windows users were able to browse it with IE in the days before Netscape and when the second choice was going with *nix and Mosaic. There were no IE days before Netscape. Netscape came first, and IE was originally just a defensive response. That's not to deny that there was a period where IE was arguably a superior browser, but IE simply would not have have been created were it not for Netscape becoming the first mainstream browser.
- brudgers 14y agoWhat evidence do you have that Microsoft would not have created a web browser but for Netscape? Or rather licensed one, because that's what they did when they could not purchase Booklink. Had Microsoft not shipped a browser with Windows, browsers would have remained obscure shareware like Netscape Navigator and AOL or Compuserve would have been the standard online experience of most people for much longer.
- jamesbritt 14y agoThe business case for IE is to hold back the progress of the web, ... Right? We would have had AJAX and DHTML so much sooner if it wasn't for Microsoft holding things back.
- bartl 14y agoHaha, that's funny... because the XMLHttpRequest thing, the main enabler of Ajax, is actually a Microsoft invention,or, should I say: "Microsoft did it first.": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XMLHttpRequest#History_and_support http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XMLHttpRequest#History_and_supp...