3 ms·
State governments in North India distribute wood during winter. See http://urbanemissions.blogspot.com/2012/11/pollution-in-delhi-winter-time-highs.html http://
by gnufied 14y ago
State governments in North India distribute wood during winter. See http://urbanemissions.blogspot.com/2012/11/pollution-in-delhi-winter-time-highs.html http://urbanemissions.blogspot.com/2012/11/pollution-in-delh...
>I guess I'm luckier than the author is with respect to the openness of our friends.
I am sure many running state governments up North(India) are aware of wood smoke being a bad thing. But I think the argument author is going for is - people are willing to set aside their scientific training/knowledge when confronted with something they have been traditionally considered okay. My Dad for example has Bachelors in physics and almsot finished masters - But I can see his argument going on the lines of, "Our body can tolerate some amount of these chemicals, it has been doing that since 10 thousand years and so it is okay".
Let me give you another example. Ayurveda . There are government run colleges in India, training people to practice Ayurveda as alternative medicine. Winter may not be same in India everywhere, but Ayurveda is. Now it has been scientifically proven that, many Ayurvedic medicines contain arsenic, lead in dangerous proportions. Beyond Yoga, their usefulness as medicine is also questionable. Try having argument with someone who believes in this (I used to be one). So, I think I understand authors POV of traditional beliefs sometimes overriding our scientific training.
- test001only 14y agoA quick Google search throws up instance of people buying medicine on-line which contains arsenics. Is this not similar to how we get fake English medicines. I do not see any source which says that ayurveda advocates adding this. Can you link me to some relevant source? I have been using medicines from arya vaidya sala one of the trusted ayurveda centres in India and never heard or had any issues.
- gnufied 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ayurveda#Scientific_appraisal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ayurveda#Scientific_appraisal See the safety section.
- test001only 14y agoThat is scary... the website for the medicine I use seems to stress that it uses herbs over metal or minerals. Hope they are safe. But the fact that there is no central body which can check and authorise these medicines is a cause for concern.