3 ms·
Seems well argued. But we will never be able to ban stoves, fireplaces, etc.
by tomjen3 14y ago
Seems well argued.
But we will never be able to ban stoves, fireplaces, etc.
- Adaptive 14y agoMaybe not ban, nor would we want to, but carbon credits could come into play and impact selection of home heating options, for example.
- ars 14y agoI assume you mean carbon dioxide credits, not carbon credits. Because for fireplaces it would have to be actual carbon credits - fireplaces release lots of carbon into the air as pollution. Incidentally people should stop being lazy and say carbon dioxide when they mean carbon dioxide - otherwise it gets confusing in situations like this where fireplaces release both carbon dioxide, and carbon, into the air.
- Adaptive 14y agoI specifically meant carbon credits. E.g. price of, for example, wood burning stoves could build in a fee/tax charged to manufacturers or importers given the nature of the product. It's not just the air pollution, it's also cutting down trees, though at least when we cut it was usually clearing farm land. As for existing fireplaces/stoves, I suppose a tax could be levied if they are the primary heat source. There are already lots of incentive based energy efficiency city and statewide programs around the nation that factor in heating method (and a lot of people eyeing the carbon credit "mining" in that case as well).
- ghaff 14y agoIt may be expired now, but a couple of years ago there was actually a tax credit for putting in a wood stove.
- eloisant 14y agoYou're actually thinking about carbon dioxide (CO2) and carbon monoxide (CO). Carbon is just the atom (C), and both carbon CO2 and CO are carbon-based molecules.
- ars 14y agoNo I'm not. Smoke AKA soot is carbon, not CO or CO2. And carbon is much more polluting than CO or CO2.
- MarkSweep 14y agoActually one city in silicon valley has already banned building new wood-burning fireplaces: http://www.losaltosonline.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=12240&Itemid=46 http://www.losaltosonline.com/index.php?option=com_content&#...
- myelin 14y agoMy hometown in New Zealand has been working to ban open fires for over a decade, due to their contribution to the city's terrible winter-time air quality. (Not helped by a temperature inversion that causes the smoke to stay near the ground rather than rise and blow away.)
- VLM 14y agoWhere I live insurance is hyper-regulated and required if you have a mortgage, and I'm not sure exactly how much or how little social engineering input the EPA had, but you're looking at your home insurance bill going up by about $2000 annually if you have a wood burner of any type in your house. Note this isn't silicon valley, and the national median household income is almost exactly $50K, so for more than half the homes in america, you're talking about a "tax" in excess of 4% of gross income merely for the privilege of owning a woodburner. A tax by any other name... Add to that the cost of obtaining wood, and the substantial mostly product liability costs of a decent wood stove (more than a grand or two) and you've changed owning a woodburner from something any joe 6 pack can have in his house to pretty much elites only. Sure, technically there's no official ban, but spending 5% of my annual income is kinda extreme as a hobby..
- eloisant 14y agoIn France there is no premium on insurance if you have a fireplace or stove, but you have to declare it, keep it to the norms and do the mandatory yearly check by a professional.