7 ms·
I will harp on about the importance of code literacy and open source / free software till the cows come home but this is the best example I know: We would neve
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
I will harp on about the importance of code literacy and open source / free software till the cows come home but this is the best example I know:
We would never vote up a article where "father writes bedtime story for daughter, Sleeping Prince rescued by Princess". Because it is commonplace because literacy is commonplace, as are pens and paper commonplace and as are the legal frameworks to be allowed to alter the published version.
In software world only the pen and paper analogy are commonplace. We need to change that
- xk_id 14y agohah :) so software is like interactive literature.
- fpgeek 14y agoExactly. I remember the days when Infocom called their text adventures interactive fiction.
- sp332 14y agoPeople still write (and play!) interactive fiction. http://inform7.com/ http://inform7.com/ and http://ifdb.tads.org/search?browse http://ifdb.tads.org/search?browse
- derleth 14y agoIt can be, with some games (Zork, GTA4, Bioshock) a lot more than others (Pong, Tetris, Tic-tac-toe, Chess). At the extreme end of games-as-literature is the Interactive Fiction world, which has been dealing with how the 'literature' and the 'game' aspects interact for decades now. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interactive_fiction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interactive_fiction Read this essay for an introduction to the concepts: http://www.ifarchive.org/if-archive/info/Craft.Of.Adventure.txt http://www.ifarchive.org/if-archive/info/Craft.Of.Adventure....
- xk_id 14y agoI actually mean "interactive literature" in a broader sense :P which includes all software, not only games. you have textbooks too, not just novels, right? :)
- Resident_Geek 14y ago> We would never vote up a article where "father writes bedtime story for daughter, Sleeping Prince rescued by Princess". Because it is commonplace because literacy is commonplace, as are pens and paper commonplace and as are the legal frameworks to be allowed to alter the published version. It's also _considerably_ easier.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoIt's only easier after twenty years training submersed in a super-literate society. The actual changes he made were minor, just in a format most of us are completely unfamiliar with. Had this been a JavaScript game I suspect it would have passed unremarked (actually that's unfair - had it been a JavaScript game of the iconic status of donkey kong then it would still be here)
- alanctgardner2 14y agoWhy do people insist on foisting "software literacy" on the general populace? In terms of skills, financial planning, cooking, interpersonal skills are all more essential than reading and writing code. The writing analogy is off anyways: not everyone can write very well. People would upvote -and buy- a children's story by, say, neil gaiman. This is not the equivalent of a throwaway story made up on the spot.
- chaz 14y agoEveryone should learn to write. This should not be taken as "learn to write a novel." The practice of writing develops skills in articulating opinions, clarifying purpose, supporting with facts, and raising clear questions -- skills useful even if pen is never put to paper. Similarly, "learning to code" is not to be taken as "be a programmer." Rather, learning to code is a means to developing skills in analyzing problems, establishing goals, breaking down big tasks into small tasks, understanding cause and effect, etc -- skills that are useful far beyond software. Learning to code isn't the only way to learn these skills, but it's a fun, easy, and accessible way to do all of them at the same time.
- clintjhill 14y agoI think this might be an over-emphasis on writing and coding for both articulation and problems solving. Doing both won't provide "everyone" better results. There are many ways people approach communication and problem solving. To say writing and coding are the best or only ways to develop these skills is in my opinion very short sighted and limiting.
- icambron 14y agoThe upvote question is easy to answer -- this is Hacker News. Of course we upvote programming. And I agree with the point about writing. And I think we shouldn't read "everyone needs programming literacy" from hacking a ROM any more than we should read "everyone needs to know woodworking" from "here's a cool piece of furniture I built for my daughter." But I will try to answer the question about foisting software literacy, since you seem to be questioning the larger trend. The question to ask here is, what do you think the skills economy will look like in 15 years? Looking casually at the trends, it's difficult to avoid the conclusion that software is eating the world. My friends in scientific research have either learned to code or are hobbled by their inability to do so. Financial institutions are increasingly just software companies with some domain expertise; I know finance people who can't get jobs because--to simplify a bit--they don't know SQL. Many non-technical office workers I know interact with a computer on some sort of programmatic level (e.g. Excel macros) and almost all of them would benefit enormously from programming literacy to help them in that. And all of that is trending upwards quickly; that's why programmers are in such high demand. Cooking is great and an important personal skill, but it's only an essential skill for chefs, whereas if you can't code, you might become the equivalent of the guy who can't use email in today's office environment. So to me, it's a question of what the world's going to look like in the future, not a question of what's most practical around the house. Forecasting the future is hard and it's an interesting debate--there are all sorts of reasons software might be less important than we might guess, and of course software people are predisposed to think software will be super valuable. But I think it's the right way to frame the discussion: if software runs the world, you really need to know it. If it doesn't, you don't. I'm not accusing you of this because I don't know you at all and your comment doesn't suggest it, but I hear a little bit of insider entitlement in a lot of programmers' arguments against increased software literacy. "I don't want all those other people jumping in and pretending they're software engineers too. The future belongs to the select few, which happens to include me. Leave software to the pros!" It's seems absurd to me that programmers don't want more people to understand the ins-and-outs of their profession...unless they feel threatened by such a thing. There's something very fishy about telling people who don't code, "Oh, yeah, don't do what I do. Learn to cook instead." Are you sure we're not just trying to keep all the marbles?
- mynameishere 14y agoWe would never vote up a article where "father writes bedtime story for daughter Yep. Because any idiot can do that. Your point?
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoHuh? The point was that because literacy is commonplace, then annindividual altering a published piece of writing for personal preferences (making it more suitable for a daughter) is also commonplace. My contention is that code literacy should / will be at the point where a "trivial" change to existing published code will not get on the front page of HN because it is as commonplace as it's "English writing" equivalent
- drdaeman 14y agoBut is writing a good child story easier than swapping two sprite sets in a blob?
- GotAnyMegadeth 14y agoIf all you were doing was changing the genders of the two main characters in another story, then yes.
- ibrahima 14y agoI think this is not necessarily the best comparison. It would be just as interesting if, for instance, a father found that all desks available were somehow inadequate for his daughter and made one for her from scratch, yet we don't go around telling people they should learn wood working. I think it would be better if more people could code but I think equating it with literacy is a bit silly.
- adaml_623 14y agoI disagree with your analogy. We do go around telling people they should obtain basic competence in DIY tasks. The 'makers' movement is pushing forward this importance in lots of places on the web and in the real world. I think everyone should be able to understand how computers are programmed and the only way to do that is basic coding lessons.
- baddox 14y agoThat's a fairly silly analogy. Even for people that are code literate, modifying a ROM (that certainly was never intended to be modified by someone outside the original development team) isn't exactly as effortless or commonplace as changing a person's name in a bunch of sentences. I make a living programming, so I would consider myself code literate, but I've never modified a ROM, so I was at least a little impressed.