3 ms·
You misunderstand the nature of the agreement. Please point to a case where MPEG-LA has given a completely sublicensable royalty-free right to someone for H.26
by DannyBee 14y ago
You misunderstand the nature of the agreement.
Please point to a case where MPEG-LA has given a completely sublicensable royalty-free right to someone for H.264, for any amount of money.
Can you get all the H.264 rights MPEG-LA offers from microsoft or apple, without going through MPEG-LA?
Does it cover all use cases?
- codex 14y agoH.264 is obsolete. MPEG-LA is moving on to H.265, the new hotness. It is telling that MPEG-LA's sub-licensing for VP8 only covers one subsequent revision of the codec. If VPx+ is augmented with H.265'ish technology in order to stay competitive, we'll see a new round of fighting.
- DannyBee 14y agoYou completely ignored the question I asked, by raising an irrelevant point :) I'll point out that despite your claim that H.264 is "obsolete", nobody still has gotten the kind of licensing google just did, despite people trying.
- codex 14y agoBoth Microsoft and Apple have patents in the H.264 patent pool. It is in their interest for H.264 licensees to go through MPEG-LA; it is not in their interest to give away sublicenses.
- DannyBee 14y agoActually, neither make much revenue from that pool. But, fine, pick someone else. AFAIK, nobody has the right to sublicense all the H.264 patent rights to others. This is one reason, for example, you have cameras and camcorders that ban professional use.
- snowwrestler 14y agoTo be fair, Google did not get this either; this deal does not give them the power to sublicense H.264 royalty-free. It gives Google the power to license VP8 to others without fear of patent suits from the MPEG-LA. But VP8 was already Google's codec to license. And they have spent years claiming it was not patent encumbered. So basically it looks to me like Google is paying to do something they always claimed they could do anyway.
- DannyBee 14y agoYes, you are essentially correct. However, my point was that nobody has the right to do this in the H.264 world, so it is in fact, still significantly different.