2 ms·
"So we are collectively engaged in a college admission 'arms race' that is almost a complete social waste, for once a set of 'good enough students' or 'good eno
by tokenadult 18y ago
"So we are collectively engaged in a college admission 'arms race' that is almost a complete social waste, for once a set of 'good enough students' or 'good enough schools' has been identified, it probably doesn't matter very much which one you choose; or if it does matter, there is no way to know in advance what the right choice is."
I'm not so sure I agree with the author's premise that there are few meaningful distinctions among top colleges (the issue each applicant has to look at). Nor am I sure that at any particular college, while the college admission office is building a class, there are not meaningful distinctions among applicants (as elements of the overall entering class that the admission office attempts to assemble). What do you think?
- Retric 18y agoI went to a local state school because I did not feel a large gap between Comp Sci there vs say MIT. My sister is trying to get into a program at Cal Arts (http://www.calarts.edu/ http://www.calarts.edu/) that accepts 30 people a year because it's by far the best program in the nation. IMO, the caliber of a top tier school has little to do with the quality of any single program. However, if you want to compete in a highly competitive area then aim for the best. PS: A friend of mine went to MIT and several years latter we ended up working in the same building making the same amount of money.
- kirse 18y agoI went to a local state school As did I. I felt that I'd rather spend time working on my own projects instead of staying up all night working on some professors' latest project. Turned out well for me at least, I made far more my senior year in college than my current income at my day job. I think the more your intended profession relies on doing to gain experience, the less going to a top-tier college matters. On the other hand, if it's through research and access to the top knowledge resources, then a top-tier school matters. For most of us as engineers / hackers, we learn much more through doing & building.
- tokenadult 18y agoAnyone applying to a college with the kind of selectivity mentioned in the submitted article would certainly want to apply to State U as a "safety" college while also applying to one of the MITs of the world. For a lot of interesting historical reasons, there probably isn't as large a gap between strong state universities and top private polytechnics as there may be between those state universities and the top liberal-arts-oriented private research universities. But, yes, every applicant has to evaluate some personal set of trade-offs, and I wouldn't expect any two applicants to have the same application list. P.S. At State U here, there is still a Scheme course that every computer science major must take, which is no longer true at MIT. So much the worse for MIT in that regard, in my opinion.