5 ms·
Half way through high school in the UK, you choose your subjects that you want to do until the end of high school and which you get your qualifications in. Bein
by petercooper 14y ago
Half way through high school in the UK, you choose your subjects that you want to do until the end of high school and which you get your qualifications in. Being a bit weird, I chose subjects I didn't know much about so I wouldn't get bored, and chose history despite never giving it a second thought before.
And.. it's probably the one subject that really stands out from high school for me now. It wasn't so much learning about facts and figures but learning about the art of studying history, the difference between primary and secondary sources, the importance of good sources, and similar general principles that have continued to be useful to me as an adult.
I guess none of this would be surprising to anyone with a good liberal arts education, but approaching history as a math and science geek, it was a real eye opener for me as a teenager.
- triplesec 14y agoI never appreciated history until I became a grad psych/soc researcher into tech/media and grokked method (and how most researchers don't, and if you think you do, you probably don't). In high school it was all facts and figured and then I gave up the boring "learn stories" stuff up for A-level maths physics and chemistry. I wish they taught history and humanities at school in the way they teach physics and chemistry practicals. I'd have loved it then, and clever nerds would understand its value!
- rplacd 14y agoI have the luck of going through one of those analytical history courses right now - but they do one thing differently: they don't even want to stoop down to prescribe on that level. Instead they give a higher-level question: "to what extent would you consider Mao's contribution to the development of modern China over-rated?" - and ask for a good argument. That inevitably that means considering counterpoints, placing them in context (and you can't go far with that if you don't understand a mite of historiography and how that in turn arises from "mainline" history), shooting them down. It's done wonders to my writing. In fact, it's been the only opportunity in my high school program to consider and create arguments of such depth - so there's your intrinsic value.
- triplesec 14y agoThat's really impressive. Was it your teacher, or the school that initiated this? I do think that some students might need more handholding than you in this particular question, however... (hell, I might get lost in that) but there is room for creating experimental learning with the ability to get in flow for all skill levels. But that's what good teaching is about.
- rplacd 14y agoYou're in luck - your guesses are just a bit too pessimistic! It's the method prescribed by my school's curriculum - they take the thing whole from a standards body. You're entirely right, though, to figure that isn't the baseline - there are plenty of "list the Xes" question that pay only lip service to considering an A line of thought versus a B line of thought. Of course, the subject's so subjectively graded that no one's guaranteed that work is proportional to the resultant grade at the highest levels - so there's remarkably little pressure and far more experimentation done than you'd expect from a high-school programme. It's a strange arrangement, but I'm lucky to have fell into it.
- agwa 14y agoThe art of studying history really stood out to me too. You're fortunate that you got that kind of history education in high school. In US high schools, history is very much about memorizing facts and figures and I think it probably ruins history for a lot of people. In my first year of high school, my history teacher was the football coach. He taught historical facts to us like he probably taught plays to his players, and I hated it. Other teachers weren't much better, but fortunately in my last year I had an inspiring history teacher, and that was enough to get me to try it out at university, where it was a radically different and much better experience. To the Americans on HN who are still in college: if you hated history in high school, give it another chance because you may be pleasantly surprised.