4 ms·
It's an economic consideration, by allowing offline play they believe they'll be leaving more money on the table than if they make it online only. They'll conve
by mattmanser 14y ago
It's an economic consideration, by allowing offline play they believe they'll be leaving more money on the table than if they make it online only. They'll convert people who would have just got a cracked version into buying it.
Unfortunately for Maxis they obviously didn't hire any programmers who had a clue how to write scalable server code.
And the result is that they have managed to lose a lot of sales in the first few key weeks because of bad reviews.
But economically speaking, sound decision, just poorly executed.
On your last point, this is an unfortunate side effect of digital goods. In Europe we can hope for a growing political movement that this is deeply anti-consumer and will be legislated against, far more likely here than in America, but it will be hard for courts to decide where to draw a line. So ultimately I doubt it will ever happen.
- sirobviouspoint 14y ago> But economically speaking, sound decision, just poorly executed. I'm not sure it counts as a 'sound decision' if you take a very risky option that hasn't panned out well for competitors in the same market on the premise that if you beat the odds, you'll get a bit more money. I think EA underestimated the cost of their "always on" DRM, and didn't adequately assess the risk against the payoff - and now have taken a business hit from it. For example, literally no one I know that I used to play Sim City with for hundreds of hours as a kid purchased this game - precisely because of EAs decisions regarding always on DRM and their history with Spore design. They've effectively driven away over a dozen people in their 20s, perfectly willing to fork over $70-100 on a game they like. (Or $200 or $300 or $1000 on a really good game they like; I'm looking at you table-top guide books, trading card games, and minifigures.) I consider that exactly the opposite of 'sound decisions'. tl;dr: You have to assess the risk that you're going to poorly execute your choice to make a 'sound decision'; I'm not sure EA did.