4 ms·
This kind of thing could be interesting. I've often bemoaned the use of HTML/Javascript as a "poor man's X server" and argued that a browser is not necessarily
by mindcrime 14y ago
This kind of thing could be interesting. I've often bemoaned the use of HTML/Javascript as a "poor man's X server" and argued that a browser is not necessarily the best way to remote out a UI. VNC, on the other hand, is designed for pushing user interfaces out remotely, so integrating the two could be a very natural step.
What'll be interesting to see, is if we can get to a point where there's a very natural handoff mechanism between the browser and VNC. Will there be, for example, urls like:
vnc://myhost.com/some_remote_desktop
that will seamlessly start a VNC viewer? If so, that starts to become really cool.
Of course, I freely admit that I don't know well VNC works over public Internet / WAN links. That was always one of the arguments against using X, that the latency of WANs / the public Internet, screwed with it and made it fairly unusable. Not sure if VNC is better in this regard or not.
- saljam 14y agoWell, you can sort of already have that with a bit of JS and NoVNC. http://kanaka.github.com/noVNC/ http://kanaka.github.com/noVNC/
- mindcrime 14y agoOh yeah? Cool, I'll check that out. I hadn't heard of NoVNC before...
- drzaiusapelord 14y agoWhy are we still messing around with ancient technology like VNC? Its terrible. It just samples screen output; it does not intelligently understand the underlying GUI so it can't really cache anything or accelerate anything. If we're going to replace HTML as a "poor man's interface" then we need to do better than VNC. Perhaps NX or RDP. Still, I'd argue that HTML as a poor man's interface is perfect. I could sit down a write a HTML-based control panel that uses next to no resources. With VNC or whatever, now I need X running on my server, a GUI window manager running, and need to write a desktop app. This isn't progress.
- mindcrime 14y agoIf we're going to replace HTML as a "poor man's interface" then we need to do better than VNC. Perhaps NX or RDP. Well, I certainly won't argue against that. But at least with VNC it's being used for the purpose it was developed for. Personally I feel like trying to build complex application UIs with HMTL/CSS/Javascript is trying to shoehorn a square peg into a round hole. Browsers are great at, well, browsing hypermedia. I'd like to see that continue and the adoption of something like RDP, NX, or $NOT_INVENTED_YET for remoting interfaces.
- spankalee 14y agoBut HTML isn't usually "remoting" an interface anymore, it _is_ the interface. This trend will only continue and solutions like VNC, NX will become unnecessary.