4 ms·
What are the biggest challenges that open-source game developers face? Can open-source games ever approach "AAA quality" game designs or art?
by cpeterso 14y ago
What are the biggest challenges that open-source game developers face? Can open-source games ever approach "AAA quality" game designs or art?
- eropple 14y agoI wouldn't worry about game design--if you've looked at an AAA game recently you can probably whiteboard out something more interesting and refine it with iteration once it's playable. What I would worry about is labor costs. People got-ta get paid. An AAA-quality game isn't something you're going to do nights-and-weekends for free when you could be leveraging those skills to get paid. You might get the help of wannabes who don't have the skills to get paid, but do you want to rely on that to push a game that by your own definition is going to require some fairly serious chops to ship? Sure, open source blah blah blah--but most open source projects that get significant, large-scale contributions have knock-on effects like being able to be easily hired for consulting gigs, that sort of thing. Game development, not so much. And artist types are not inculcated into the open-source world to nearly the extent of programmers, so I find it unlikely that you'll be able to really source all the media you need. There's usually a ton of overly naive hand-flapping about how you have Wesnoth and Nexuiz and the rest, but if you look at the games, they're not what a reasonable person would call an AAA title on the level of a Starcraft 2 or a Halo (and Nexuiz in particular is based on a closed-source game engine opened up years after its licensing viability was over). I'm sure you can make good, fun games in an open-source way (because it has been done) but I strongly doubt you'll make anything that's competitive in the AAA market space without accepting that you're lighting a few million dollars on fire (because let's get real, effectively nobody's going to pay you a dime for it). . (This is also why I laughed at the guy upthread who said "oh, the market should solve this, someone should start a Kickstarter for a city sim game!". That's not how Kickstarter works and it's not how somebody who can do math approaches a game. To get attention for a high-ask Kickstarter you need a decent chunk of work already done, and by the time you get there the shitbomb of SimCity will probably have departed and taken its stink elsewhere. To build a game on the scale of SimCity in a length of time that won't have your backers screaming for your head, you're going to need a couple million dollars. With extremely rare, you're-not-it exceptions, Kickstarter backers laugh at such requests. It's the "zeitgeist projects" that manage to hit their targets and then a high multiple thereof--and the worst thing that can happen to you if you're hoping to be one of those projects is that you make your goal and no more. Economies of scale suck for the ambitious, because no matter how cool your idea, people gotta get paid.)