4 ms·
First, why is of paramount importance. So, yes I do care why. I never defended his murder of those two people. I am not saying he is not a monster. What I am
by samstave 14y ago
First, why is of paramount importance. So, yes I do care why.
I never defended his murder of those two people. I am not saying he is not a monster.
What I am saying is that too many people, and it would seem yourself included, use that as justification for the state to murder people.
Do you care why the LAPD shot up the two newspaper delivery ladies? What about the ramming and injuring of hte white surfer guy?
DO you care why the LAPD was able to justify warrantless entry to ~400 homes in their manhunt?
What we are seeing is that the LEOs and the Fed would like to leave the structure of our system at the door whenever they have a threat to their power.
Context is critically important. Having both truthful facts and full context does not threaten the reality of the situation.
Obfuscating either, however, has far too much potential for abuse.
In this case, the LAPD pulled out all the stops in going after someone who pulled out all his own stops in his effort to fight against what he perceived as an insurmountable injustice against him.
I am not defending his actions - I am pointing out what the facts of the situation were.
I am not sympathetic to Dorner, nor am I sympathetic to the LAPD.
I am sympathetic to the fact that there were multiple people murdered, this is inclusive of Dorner himself. (because allowing the LAPD/Sheriff to murder people because they are 1) embarrassed 2) angry 3) scared 4) incompetent 5) arrogant with their power, is never OK.)
- tptacek 14y agoNo, I don't think the killing of Dorner is comparable to his murder of Monica Quan. Quan was targeted, stalked, and deliberately killed while unarmed. The officers surrounding Dorner were in a confrontation with an armed suspect who had pledged to trade his life for the opportunity to kill police officers and who had just that day outside that exact cottage killed another police officer. He was not an inert submissive object inside the building; he was trying to kill them with more diligence and intent than they him.
- samstave 14y agoI am not comparing the two. Both are murders. Burning down a house and being recorded on tape as having "talked about" it (i.e. planned it) is not ok. I was not saying he was inert or submissive - but sorry LEOs are supposedly trained to take on all situations. They are extremely well armed and equipped. Burning down random property to get their guy is not an OK tactic.