3 ms·
The road is being paved. What is to stop local law enforcement units from having weaponized drones within 5 years? Honestly, what I beleive will happen is FLIR
by samstave 14y ago
The road is being paved. What is to stop local law enforcement units from having weaponized drones within 5 years?
Honestly, what I beleive will happen is FLIR enabled drones assisting in all LEO efforts.
Take a look at my friends video he took this weekend.
This is a tri-copter with FPV goggles he uses to fly it. He built one that can hold several pounds and has a gymbal for holding a full size camera.
http://vimeo.com/61156472 http://vimeo.com/61156472
Here is the setup:
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1718160&page=40#post24085992 http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1718160&...
Weaponizing is the easy part - paving the multi-year path until its "authorized" is the tricky part which they are currently attempting.
- tptacek 14y agoThe road you're talking about is technology. The road Rand Paul is talking about is endless power grabs from the legislative branch by the executive branch. The road you're talking about is real; the road Paul is talking about is fanciful. The Senate voted to give Bush and his successors this authority 98-0. Incidentally: as long as we're careful about ensuring that technology doesn't allow LEOs to gin up probable cause or introduce evidence that should be excluded, I'm not sure why I should on general principles oppose adoption of technology by LEOs.
- samstave 14y agoThe issue is that while it is subtle, the constant adoption of greater and greater technical capability by the LEOs is that its a slow, but constant stepping path toward enabling tyranny. The reason being that 1) a extremely technically enabled LEO system is one that is completely abstracted from the reality of its citizenry. 2) it creates an institutionalized dependence and sense of superiority on and due to said technological capabilities. 3) create a propoensity to rely on the technology more-so than the human instincts and filters, thus, we see much more of a "system" which will victimize people more regularly. Any and all murders by police will continue to be classified as "unfortunate" yet nothing will be done. Police are already far too poorly trained to deal with anything remotely stressful without shooting first. I am fully opposed to any and all pushing of technology onto an already overly trigger happy, callous system in lieu of more, actual training.
- tptacek 14y agoThis is a very good reason not to give the police armed drones, or, for that matter, new arms of any sort. I'm right with you there. The militarization of police forces is a real problem. It is not a very good reason not to give the police better surveillance technology. Crime victimizes more people than police forces in the US do. I'm not saying that means LEOs don't victimize people; they do. I'm not saying that means we should turn a blind eye to police abuse; we should not. But when we do risk/reward calculations, we need to keep in mind that the greater ambient threat is of crime, not police abuse. Sometimes, the police will ask for things that tip the scale the other direction. But we have to make a case for how; we can't just assume it. Keep in mind: I'm one of the people laughing and cheering at the guy in the video saying "no thanks, no, I won't be pulling into secondary screening" at the CBP checkpoints; I've given to the ACLU. Surveillance is scary. It's just not intrinsically bad; it's bad in a context-dependent way.
- anigbrowl 14y agoWeaponizing is the easy part - paving the multi-year path until its "authorized" is the tricky part which they are currently attempting. I don't think that's true. Can you document such attempts, by which I mean back your argument up with citations instead of hand-waving and anecdote?
- samstave 14y agoThe whole current debate about using drones on US soil, for recon or tactical means is the most relevant citation. The fact that DHS just bought 2,700 MRAPS for domestic use is another. We are actively militarizing the police forces in the US by giving them tactics, training, equipment weapons and capabilities of a veteran national military. The fact that Holder and Paul are even having this discussion, with loosely defined terms such as "engaged in combat", I believe is the first few steps down this quickly steepening path. Lets hope that I am wrong.
- tptacek 14y agoThe militarization of US law enforcement is on orthogonal issue to the one Holder and Paul are debating. DHS bought 2700 APCs because some company sold them. It's a travesty to be sure, and it will have knock-on effects of generating more "tactical teams" and thus more pointlessly aggressive raids, but it is not evidence of intent to put US law enforcement on a more martial footing. It's really more evidence of fiscal corruption than anything else.
- anigbrowl 14y agoSo, having a debate on the limitations of government power means a creeping expansion of government power to you? I don't buy it. Please do not link to the Wikipedia article on the Overton Window. The war on terror is a legislative fact and has been for ~12 years. If you're going to assert an expansion of the legal authority for weaponized drones beyond military theaters, then I need to see something from a third party, and by something I mean a link to a bill or advocacy of such expansion, not more hand-waving.
- samstave 14y ago