4 ms·
Maybe I'm just not as social as other people, but bill splitting and chipping in has never been a problem for me. Ever. On a handful of occasions I've had som
by mgkimsal 14y ago
Maybe I'm just not as social as other people, but bill splitting and chipping in has never been a problem for me. Ever. On a handful of occasions I've had someone in a group I was in say they were strapped, and I've covered their portion of something. Others have done the same for me. Someone buys lunch for me if I have no cash, I get their lunch next week.
Buying a gift in an office for someone? Well, I've not worked in an office for a while, but cash used to work well (and didn't leave a digital trail of who you're giving money to).
Maybe there's some bigger play going on in this market, but it's always felt to me like a solution looking for a problem.
EDIT - on the few occasions where I've 'split a bill' with someone out at a bar/club/restaurant, I always feel I get stiffed, because I don't drink alcohol - so getting a $100 bill split 5 ways... well... I just had a $3 pepsi - why the hell do we "split" this equally?
- untog 14y agoI don't think anyone has an issue with actually having the money to contribute to the bill. And if everyone is paying by card it's pretty simple, but once you get cash involved giving everyone the right change can be a huge pain. I've had a lot of success using Venmo for this purpose.
- danvideo 14y agoYou guys are probably right about the value of this app in a restaurant especially vs. cash or asking servers to split the bill--- however, I think there's a less obvious value for this tool in offices, for example, where people split gifts or cakes or lottery ante-ups together... not everyone might be physically in the office on a given particular day, etc... uh, edit: haven't looked into Venmo, doing so now
- Domenic_S 14y agoI feel that. We can be old geezers together. We've had a solution to this "problem" for centuries: cash. If your group is too lazy to ask the server to split the tab 4 ways, what in the world makes you think they're all going to pull out their apps and pay this way? Then there's inevitably someone who doesn't have a smartphone, or doesn't have that app, or doesn't want to sign up for a new payment account, or doesn't like using credit cards online, or whatever. More than a couple times I've been sitting there with people trying to add up their totals, some taking out cash, some taking out cards, arguing over who pays what, and just paid the whole thing and asked them to buy me coffee or a meal or whatever when they can.
- larrys 14y ago"We can be old geezers together" Not only that but it's like Nero is fiddling while Rome burns. North Korea is building up an arsenal to strike the US. And our best and brightest are solving big problems like this.
- jff 14y agoThe best and brightest are working as US diplomats, or are doing intelligence gathering on NK's capabilities, or are maintaining our nuclear arsenal. It's only within the HN, Silicon Valley echo chamber that the "best and brightest" are working on social networks for cats.
- dregitsky 14y agoWith restaurant bills, things get rather complicated when everyone orders different items, someone bought a Groupon, etc. Unless people are OK with over/under paying, a bill splitting app can be pretty useful to figure out what everyone actually owes. Cash works well when everyone has it, but from what I've seen that doesn't happen all that often. Also, you get a lot of restaurants that refuse to itemize the bill (maybe their point of sale system doesn't support it), and sometimes they'll only take 1 credit card. Integration with payment apps is great for that. It goes beyond saving time...an app can help make sure people pay up and the IOUs don't become permanent. Disclosure: I recently released Grouptuity (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.grouptuity https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.grouptuity), which tries to solve these problems and integrates with Venmo.
- mgkimsal 14y agoUsually, there's a minimum charge ('gratuity') for parties of 6 or 8 or more, so they better damn well split the bills for us. I've had it be a problem twice in the past 6 years of dining out, and once was sort of my own doing (we had a party of 24 on a Friday night - I just paid it as a single thing vs having everyone split it up - it was an unusual event). The other time it happened was a party of 5 and the server refused to split up the bill. We all chipped in something, but I don't go back there anymore. Maybe it's a bigger problem in some areas of the world, but not mine.
- camh 14y agoI've used it very successfully for vacation and for a whiskey fund for the office. Usually more expensive charges or ones that include a lot of people. I have not used it to split dinner or a bar tab. That's cash.
- ultimoo 14y agoIt is actually a very widely used application for people living with roommates or other non-institutionalized housing arrangements where groceries and other monthly expenses are split on a regular basis -- college folk, young entrepreneurs, cash strapped people etc. I believe it is a pretty rife market -- rentshare.com, splitwise.com, billmonk, reconcileapp.com etc.
- T-R 14y agoBill split apps are really nice if you live in a shared housing/dorm type situation. At our hacker house, we're always going out for dinner together, or sending someone out to get food, or ordering groceries on Instacart - saves so much time not having to use cash, or keep track of who got what beforehand. Really wish this was an option while I was in college. We've been using Split&Pay ( https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/splitandpay/id593386557 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/splitandpay/id593386557 ) - payment is really smooth (just click the button in the e-mail and you're done), particularly since we all already have WePay accounts, since that's how we organize our rent payments. Full disclosure: Author of the app is one of my housemates, and founding engineer of WePay.
- Domenic_S 14y ago> saves so much time not having to use cash ...really?
- Falling3 14y agoI don't really have a use for the split myself. But I definitely understand that it could be easier than cash. I never have cash. Ever. My paycheck is direct deposit. Almost everywhere I got accepts debit cards - even vending machines and meters. I occasionally get money out for a farmer's market or similar event, but it's always for something specific and very much the exception to my spending habits.
- T-R 14y agoYeah, really. For one, no one in the house carries cash, and no one wants to - that was even more true in college when a lot was paid for via campus ID. Not everyone has transportation to an ATM, either. More importantly though, when people are splitting bills more than twice a week (often with different subsets of the group), getting paid back isn't just a pain, it gets to be a source of tension in the house - really quickly no one wants to split bills, because no one wants to have to harass their friends about money. With the bill split app, the person who pays racks up reward points on their credit card, and all they have to do is type in how much everyone owes, and that's the end of it. Everyone else clicks a button and they're paid up.
- toddmorey 14y agoI do think it's a real issue, but I think it's nuts that everyone encounters a 4% + 99¢ processing fee just to move money around among friends. Our payments system is in need of a serious update.
- 001sky 14y agoIn simple terms, the value proposition is "not having to think about it". An app that adds functionality (ie, not-being-stupid about it) with practicality (not having to think about it) is sort of a classic win/win. The app that provides a bit of an audit trail, and allows for pre-negotiation, etc could even be tweaked over time to balance out even if simple stochastics dont do so by themselves.
- jmathai 14y agoSquare. I'm happy footing the bill if I can get payments from everyone else via credit card right at the spot. Cash also works but more than likely everyone will have a credit card. If they don't, then cash.
- cbhl 14y agoNot to mention Venmo, Dwolla, PayPal, Interac Email Money Transfer...