4 ms·
"If it turns out that we actually can communicate data via quantum entanglement, we now know that it’ll be much faster than the speed of light." No, no, no, no
by jerf 14y ago
"If it turns out that we actually can communicate data via quantum entanglement, we now know that it’ll be much faster than the speed of light."
No, no, no, no, no. No. No. No. Quantum entanglement can not be used to communicate in that manner, on its own. This is well-established, and given the how mathematical the establishment is, it's not going to change anytime soon.
No. No. No. Stop that. No.
- olgeni 14y agoToo bad - it could have saved a few telecommuters at Yahoo!.
- abstractbill 14y agoEarlier on, the article says: "As of our current understanding of quantum mechanics, though, it is impossible to send data using quantum entanglement, preserving the theory of relativity. A lot of work is being done in this area, though, and some physicists believe that faster-than-light communication might be possible with some clever manipulation of entangled particles." Shame it's so vague about those some physicists!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- cwzwarich 14y agoThere are skeptics who maintain that the various "no-signaling theorems" in physics are simply "begging the question" and rely on hypotheses that are too strong, e.g. http://people.uleth.ca/~kent.peacock/FQXi_v2.pdf http://people.uleth.ca/~kent.peacock/FQXi_v2.pdf
- nessus42 14y agoYes, they shouldn't get their hopes up too much. Since the Many Worlds Interpretation is the simplest one, it is also the most likely one. With MWI there is no spooky action at a distance, and nothing is actually transmitted faster than the speed of light.
- wamatt 14y ago> Since the Many Worlds Interpretation is the simplest one, it is also the most likely one The simplest defeasible claim in 2013, is still: "we don't know". Consider, 'How does the sun come up every day?' Answer A: God makes it happen. Answer B: The earth is a spinning geoid that rotates eastwards, once about it's axis, roughly every 24 hours. However most of the effect is not related to the orbits of either the sun or earth, with respect to each other. The sun "rises" is more an observational effect of a stationary observer on the surface of the earth, having their field of view rotated. (For the record, answer B can be improved of course, though that's not the point here) "Simplicity" does not mean a catchall (Answer A). It also does not necessarily mean linguistic brevity either. There is debate around what it means and it's beyond the scope of my comment[1]. This is the problem with string theory, that also tends to be popular among the MWI crowd too. It's overly broad and the math looks pretty, but those are not sufficient conditions for a good scientific theory. (Oblig xkcd [1]) MWI, like string theory, makes little if any falsifiable and testable claims. [1]http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/simplicity/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/simplicity/ [2]http://xkcd.com/171/ http://xkcd.com/171/
- eridius 14y agoA fair definition of "simplicity" is relying on the fewest (or simplest) assumptions. "God made it happen" relies on the most complicated assumption possible, that of an omnipotent god. It is never the simplest answer, except linguistically.
- Eliezer 14y agoUm, no. MWI is simplest in the strict, formal, information-theoretic, Kolmogorov-complexity sense, while fitting the data to equal precision with any competitor. That's kinda the whole point of MWI. http://lesswrong.com/lw/q3/decoherence_is_simple/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/q3/decoherence_is_simple/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/q4/decoherence_is_falsifiable_and_testable/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/q4/decoherence_is_falsifiable_and_te...
- wamatt 14y ago
- OGinparadise 14y agoBut the title leads people to click. Why let about the little details like truth and math interfere with that?