6 ms·
I hope that's not what the article is suggesting. The way I read it, it's more like what Google and Facebook do: very sophisticated tracking of multiple factor
by rwmj 14y ago
I hope that's not what the article is suggesting. The way I read it, it's more like what Google and Facebook do: very sophisticated tracking of multiple factors (your IP, geolocation, browser identity, second-factor, etc) to find out if it's really "you" logging in, or someone who's just got your password.
The problems are:
(1) This will never work for a single vendor (unless it's a massive vendor like Amazon, and they're already doing it). It's something the bank has to do so it can tie together all the information about you.
(2) Banks have proven to be totally useless at online security in the past, and I don't see that changing any time soon.
(3) Google-style security can be a bit annoying when you really are logging in from an internet cafe in a foreign country.
- tommccabe 14y agoThreatmetrix assigns a fraud risk/score based on multiple factors, including the geolocation, IP, & browser. Additionally (to your point #1), they anonymize data across their customers and alert if a device has been flagged in a fraudulent transaction elsewhere. On top of their own customers, they partner with Cybersource so there is quite a network of data behind their fraud analysis. (I don't work for Threatmetrix- but I do use their product as provided via Cybersource.)
- brandonb 14y agoHey Tom -- I'd love to see if we could help with fraud even above and beyond what Cybersource/TM do. Feel free to e-mail me: brandon@siftscience.com!
- brandonb 14y agoThat's exactly it. It's important to look at a whole bunch of factors. For example, fraudsters tend to go directly to the payments page, whereas good users will browse around the site before making a purchase. There are tons of little signals like that which allow you to distinguish legitimate users from the fraudsters. We don't do things like two-factor auth -- in general, we believe in minimizing friction. It's a better user experience, and if you can prevent fraud without burdening the user, why not? We have more information with some examples of signals our system uses here: https://siftscience.com/large-scale-machine-learning https://siftscience.com/large-scale-machine-learning
- paulsutter 14y agoIsn't the first rule of fraud detection not to talk about rules you use to detect fraud? ;)
- solistice 14y agoIt is. If you spill the beans that you are checkin staying on site and browsing before buying, and it'll take a week till there's a tool for simulating that.
- pfredrich 14y agoIt's a trap.
- segmondy 14y agoThere is no security through obscurity only illusions of it.
- dalore 14y agoIt's analysing behaviour for patterns. If you let out what patterns you're looking for then those patterns change.
- sheri 14y agoWouldn't the patterns change after the fraudsters realize they are not working?
- wtracy 14y agoWill people please stop saying that in this context? Merchant-side fraud prevention schemes are not security. They are heuristics for reducing the number of bad transactions that the vendor has to handle. Algorithms should be air-tight. Yes, the best way to ensure that they are is to make them public. Heuristics by definition are not airtight. The best way to get utility from them is to keep their nature hidden from parties trying to abuse the system.
- fivre 14y agoGoogle's bogon detection is also annoying if you (legitimately) use proxy/VPN services. Seriously, they blocked the entirety of Linode's IPv6 range and there's absolutely nothing you can do about it. Well, you can submit a false flag report, but Google customer support for suspected bots isn't great.