3 ms·
This post is a logical mess. The author might do better writing another one in a few years or learning to use diagrams to convey architecture (but for god's sak
by contingencies 14y ago
This post is a logical mess. The author might do better writing another one in a few years or learning to use diagrams to convey architecture (but for god's sake don't bother with UML!).
Architecturally, the changes discussed seem to be (1) From a standard protocol to some customization for premature optimization purposes (unmeasured results), and back to a standard protocol. (2) From service abstraction through higher-layer communication to service-dependency through direct database connectivity. (3) From code duplication between client/server to the use of a centralized model. (4) From multiple codebases to a single codebase.
My take: (1) Is premature optimization, needless complexity and was ultimately a waste of time. (2) A change so completely fundamentally different with a view towards system architecture (security, resource allocation, proxy/WAN/potential-client-range, etc.) that it is hard to analyze; ultimately it suggests a complete misunderstanding or rescoping of the original problem. (3) Generating code or behaviour from models is very often a great idea. While up-front complexity may appear slightly larger, it means you can retarget your code to other languages/platforms much more easily, without the inefficies and syntax-learning overheads of partial-but-similar strategies through runtime abstraction libraries. (These are occasionally useful for very-specific requirements, but that's a tangent.) (4) See 2.
- rossjudson 14y agoYour insult is a logical error. You might do better writing another one after googling David Maciver. Always remember! Google before insulting! My take: You failed to to note the confessional tone of the piece. You also failed to note that even very smart people (see Google point above) can sometimes get sucked into wise-by-step, terrible-in-aggregate decisions.
- contingencies 14y agoNo insult intended. However, congratulations on exhibiting lowest form of wit. I was just trying to extract some meaning from the piece that was practical. Sorry to ruffle anyone's feathers... I'll get back to duckduckgo-ing 'totalitarian panopticons of childlike presentation'.