3 ms·
Sheldrake's actual talk is pretty decent, and this is another example of internet skeptics being intellectually dishonest. The blogger's entire argument is that
by Alex3917 14y ago
Sheldrake's actual talk is pretty decent, and this is another example of internet skeptics being intellectually dishonest. The blogger's entire argument is that Sheldrake is saying that the speed of light isn't constant, which he explicitly never says. The ironic thing is that this blog post actually proves Sheldrake's point.
- pfraze 14y agoI probably won't have the time to watch the talk. What does Sheldrake say?
- brockf 14y agoHe says the speed of light fluctuates, but the scientific community simply says its constant by definition.
- Alex3917 14y ago"He says the speed of light fluctuates" He never says this. He says the measurements fluctuate, which means the speed of light itself may (or may not) fluctuate. But we will never know because it's been defined as a constant.
- brockf 14y agoOk. In related news, I tried to measure the length of a day the other day (just to make sure we're not being had) and it was 29 hours long! My watch was broken, but still - 29 hours! Could it be that some days are 29 hours long? We'll never know, I guess. But I personally have my doubts, and plan to share them in a future TEDx talk.
- Alex3917 14y agoThe talk is about how philosophical materialists have subverted science by using it to push their dogma.
- brockf 14y agoHis talk is filled with nonsense. In the beginning, I was going along with him ("yes - let's challenge scientific assumptions") but from the point at which he said rats can learn essentially telepathically, I was out. And it just got worse and worse.
- aneth4 14y agoWhy would you not entertain the idea that rats can learn telepathically? As an open minded scientist, would you not want to test for evidence of such a phenomenon instead of following in the footsteps of flat-earthers, who tune out at the first sign of an idea that seems to question their beliefs? There is so much about the universe we don't even begin to understand, from why anything exists at all to the nature and quality of consciousness. What baffles me is that all these supposedly open-minded rational people can presume to know so much to be "nonsense" about which science does not even claim to know anything at all.
- brockf 14y agoThere have been countless attempts at observing telepathic-like phenomena and not a single one has produced anything. I'm not sure why you are saying science claims not to know about telepathy. Every scientist I know would claim it doesn't exist because it's theoretically impossible and empirically never been observed.
- aneth4 14y agoTheoretically impossible? Please explain. Even the Christian god is not "theoretically impossible."
- GuiA 14y agoDirect quote from the talk, at 4:20 : "Dogma 8: your mind is inside your head. All your consciousness is the activity of your brain and nothing more. Dogma 9: psychic phenomena like telepathy are impossible. Your thoughts and intentions cannot have any effect at a distance because your mind is inside your head. Therefore all the apparent evidence for telepathy and other psychic phenomena is illusory." Sheldrake says these are science's "dogmas" (there are 10), and that they are all wrong. Draw your own conclusions.
- Alex3917 14y ago"Sheldrake says these are science's 'dogmas' (there are 10), and that they are all wrong." No he doesn't. You're just hearing what you want to hear.
- GuiA 14y agoAre you kidding me dude? At 1"40: "[I] take the ten dogmas or assumptions of science, and turn them into questions, seeing how well they stand up if you look at them scientifically. None of them stand up very well." So "telepathy doesn't exist" does not stand up to scientific questioning? Come on man, you're better than this.
- Alex3917 14y ago>"[I] take the ten dogmas or assumptions of science, and turn them into questions, seeing how well they stand up if you look at them scientifically. None of them stand up very well." He's saying that the evidence for the 'ten dogmas' being true is weak, not that there is strong evidence for them being false. >So "telepathy doesn't exist" does not stand up to scientific questioning? He's not saying that telepathy exists, he's saying there isn't good reason to believe that it's impossible.
- GuiA 14y agoHere's the thing though, and this will be the last comment from me on this thread as it gets tiring; people of your sort are great when it comes to playing "he said/she said" games, finding something to "tutut" about at every sentence– but when it comes to actually producing results, actually bringing something to the table other than an ego, there is nothing. Not a single man standing.
- Steuard 14y agoStarting around 14:48 in the video, he says, "I myself think the constants may vary, quite considerably, well, within narrow limits, but they may all be varying. And I think the day will come when the scientific journals, like Nature, have a weekly report on the constants, like the stock market reports in newspapers. 'This week big G was slightly up, the charge on the electron was down, the speed of light held steady,' and so on." If Sheldrake expects the journal Nature to eventually publish weekly reports on the current value of the speed of light, that's a pretty clear statement that he thinks the speed of light isn't constant. And making that claim is pretty convincing evidence that Sheldrake doesn't understand the physics that he's so upset about. If he actually understood what is meant by "we've now defined the speed of light to be a constant", he would phrase his argument in different terms. (It would still have a lot of major flaws, from the sound of it, but at least he wouldn't be immediately showing that he doesn't know what he's talking about.) But even leaving aside that specific error, I still disagree with his premise. I work in high energy physics, and it's routine to see people discussing frameworks where our measured fundamental constants could change. Practically any mention of a "multiverse" in physics or cosmology draws on that idea, for instance. If there's a scientific dogma that's supposed to make us blindly reject those possibilities, it seems to be remarkably ineffective.