5 ms·
It's time to get beyond the shock and outrage at the stone-walling occurring, now, at every level of government, and take a good hard look at what's motivating
by javajosh 14y ago
It's time to get beyond the shock and outrage at the stone-walling occurring, now, at every level of government, and take a good hard look at what's motivating Holder. We are asking him to empathize with us - the least we can do is empathize with him.
First things first: Swartz is small potatoes. Holder deals with a lot of things, not the least of which is fielding questions about the legality of drone strikes on US soil [1], or writing memos about Gitmo or torture [2]. The handling or mis-handling of a single case is nothing to Eric Holder, especially since his boss is not up for reelection.
Second thing: the default position for any government leader is to back up your people. It's easier that way. If everyone in government backs up their people, coupled with unapologetic denials of wrong-doing, you have a much more comfortable government for one and all - at least between elections. But hey, 4 years of total autonomy is far better than suffering constant public scrutiny and having to react to it. This is even more powerful if you have the judiciary on your side and, since you're all on the same team, that's more likely than not.
In summary, Eric Holder doesn't care about this case, and has assumed the default position of someone in his station: deny-everything. It would have been quite remarkable, in hindsight, for him to have done anything else.
Clearly this is not a good outcome: we want an Attorney General who shares our sensibilities, and in this case, we wanted someone in that role who perceives the fact that the federal prosecutor overstepped their bounds and drove a sensitive soul into oblivion for actions which caused no-one any harm. We want someone who understands that merely to be prosecuted is a severe punishment in time and treasure. We want someone who understands the difference between someone who breaks the law out of a heartfelt spirit of doing the right thing, and someone who breaks the law out of malicious, selfish intent.
Sadly, I can think of no other way to address this problem than to keep this in mind for the next election.
[1] http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2013/03/05/173572444/president-could-in-theory-order-drone-strike-inside-u-s-holder-says http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2013/03/05/173572444/pre...
[2] http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/mar/06/pentagon-iraqi-torture-centres-link?CMP=twt_gu http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/mar/06/pentagon-iraqi-t...
EDIT: P.S. I really like looking at inexplicable/horrible things like a software bug. Rather than indulge in pointless, impotent anger, treat the anger as a signal that your understanding of the system is flawed, and think through the forces at work. It's hard to get in the head of an insider, especially right after they pissed you off - but chances are they didn't want to piss you off. They didn't care about you at all.
Then, when your cogent analysis is through and you understand the system and how it can be fixed, you turn your anger back on a little and RIP THAT SHIT APART AND FIX IT.
- jeremyjh 14y agoHow about just someone who understands that a felony is a lifetime sentence? That is what blows me away. He defends their offer of "3, 4, 5" months like its totally reasonable to permanently disenfranchise a citizen whose misconduct was so negligibly harmful.
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>negligibly harmful I would actually use the term "virtually harmless" because it conveys the truth more accurately.
- andrewljohnson 14y agoWhile I have always been pro-Aaron, your comment isn't true. For a common felon, any time is a life sentence, but not for a talented techie with this kind of rap. For example, Kevin Mitnick is a very successful guy post prison. Aaron would have always been able to find work too, if not vote.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoThe poster you replied to didn't say anything about economic welfare. Being disenfranchised is nothing to be taken lightly -- especially when it happens at the scale it currently does, to the point that it could actually alter the outcome of elections.
- commandar 14y agoAnd when you're someone as politically-minded as Aaron.
- delinka 14y agoIt is a life sentence! For the rest of one's life, a convicted/admitted felon may not vote, has his 2nd amendment rights stripped away. For. Life. ETA: This makes me think that perhaps there should be a law to prevent 'placing oneself into the status of felon' (by admitting guilt, taking a plea deal, w/e) and that one must be convicted of a felony to be labeled "felon" and thus be required to live with the lifelong restrictions.