3 ms·
I agree with this. 1000/hr will make all jobs unfeasible - on the basis that a job is a way to earn money by offering greater value in labour than in wage. Bu
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
I agree with this.
1000/hr will make all jobs unfeasible - on the basis that a job is a way to earn money by offering greater value in labour than in wage.
But what if we lived in a society where solar powered robots did everything and one guy earnt all the money for just pressing the power switch at 8am each day?
How would we share out the bounties of wealth these robots made? Giving everyone a job at below cost might be one way. Not the best but it is a way.
So I suggest that the coming world will have vast wealth, and fewer jobs - and we need to find new ways to make society fair for all. Because an unfair society is a Bad Thing.
Edit: tried to be cleaerer
- tolmasky 14y agoI don't understand this view. Every time I see people spending hours of their time watching harlem shake videos or any other silly nonsense on the web, I am heartened that there are infinite jobs in entertaining each other and providing "non essential" services. OK sure, robots will take over construction and heavy lifting, leaving only a "super class" of surgeons and whatnot still able to get any of the jobs we recognize today. But I think we are far away from robots taking away other very human jobs. I pay for a twitch.tv subscription so I can see StarCraft games in 720p+. I literally pay other people to play video games. This is not some strange oddity, this is the future. Remember: once upon a time it was a full time job for just about everyone in a society to get food, take care of children, and just generally do the bare minimum to survive. I'm sure they look at the world we live in today as "post-scarcity" the same way we imagine a world of tomorrow where robots do all of our duties. When agriculture introduced surplus into our society, it didn't cause a collapse. It instead allowed art and science to be born. Just as those early humans would have scoffed at Michelangelo getting a paycheck for putting colors on walls, so to does this possible future seem frivolous to us. But it is no more frivolous than all the current people employed in our current economy convincing each other to buy things we don't need. If or when machines do everything we consider essential now, I assure you we will find new things to do with our time, some will be better than others at these new things, and thus we will pay each other to do them.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThere is a difference between being paid to do a job and a job that increases the total wealth in the world. There are two ways to look at this - the pg style do something people want (such as play Starcraft well) and a more physicist viewpoint of decreasing amount of energy needed to achieve a given outcome. (Yeah that definition needs some work but it is intuitively measurable) Anyway, if robots do all the stuff that is physicist-style Like farming or manufacture and humans then sit around doing arts and crafts, that's great for humans - as long as there is some means of distributing the wealth (energy transformed into goods?) - and preferably a fair means of doing so We could just hand out food, or give everyone a "job" - but correcting the compensation when the job is not actually productive is hard. We are going to go into a world where economics will have to catch up. A job is essentially an overloaded concept - it does two things, distributes wealth and is an actual means of wealth creation. Split the two and we are in uncharted waters, but splitting the two we are.
- tolmasky 14y agoI don't understand why you think any rules change just because the jobs being done change. This revolution of automation has largely already taken place, and I would argue that the automation isn't even the important part. What difference does it make if all food is generated by robots vs today's reality of most food being generated by a tiny percentage of the humans with the huge help of technology? I certainly don't generate my own food, and I don't do anything very essential by the "physicist viewpoint", and yet I am still able to acquire food. Most people in this country don't farm and are still able to get food despite doing "non physicist" jobs. I didn't need a job handed to me or invented to keep me busy. My job is completely non-essential and would have made absolutely no sense 1000 years ago. It however exists because of technology and surplus. The guy playing StarCraft makes money. He then uses said money to buy food from guy who owns the crops, just like today. Its no different than how soccer players play for people for money. What is the complexity here? Why do you think we will need to figure out means of "distribution"?
- lifeisstillgood 14y ago
- nathan_long 14y ago>> 1000/hr will make all jobs unfeasible - on the basis that a job is a way to earn money by offering greater value in labour than in wage. >> But what if we lived in a society where solar powered robots did everything and one guy earnt all the money for just pressing the power switch at 8am each day? This is highly unrealistic. 1) We are a very long way from having robots able to do most human jobs. 2) There will always be scarce resources. Even if you could 3D print houses for pennies, land, access to desirable events and people, etc will be scarce, coveted, and distributed to the highest bidder. Let's talk about policies that work well in our actual, current world.