7 ms·
The inflection point is the productivity-per-hour of workers. Whenever wages get higher than productivity-per-hour, they cause unemployment. However, whenever
by eli_gottlieb 14y ago
The inflection point is the productivity-per-hour of workers. Whenever wages get higher than productivity-per-hour, they cause unemployment.
However, whenever productivity-per-hour is much higher than wages (as it has been, on the median, and increasingly so, since the 1970s), we can afford to raise wages without trouble.
So the question is: what's the productivity of minimum-wage jobs? Also: if their productivity really is that low, shouldn't anyone unable to obtain a living wage when already in full-time work just be taken out of that job and subsidized by the state wholesale? I mean, doing otherwise has given us massive effective subsidies to Wal-Mart and other low-wage, low-productivity employers who are essentially fleecing the public of its hard-won antipoverty dollars.
Or it could turn out Wal-Mart employees actually do produce $10/hour of value, and the company was just being exploitative all along...
- crusso 14y agoUnless Walmart is in control of all jobs in the market or unless Walmart and other employers are illegally colluding by sticking to a low wage agreement - the value of productivity per hour is what workers at Walmart are negotiating. If Walmart isn't paying people what they feel they are worth then they're free to go elsewhere to redefine what their labor is worth. just be taken out of that job and subsidized by the state wholesale That completely eliminates the ability of some to find part time work to supplement their income. Maybe a mom without any real skills in the job market would like to work a few extra hours at an entry level job to bring home some spending money for herself and her family. Maybe a teenager would like to get some experience and earn some gas money while in high school. By eliminating jobs through manipulating the minimum wage so thoughtlessly, you would destroy vital segments of the job market that serve a purpose.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoUnless Walmart is in control of all jobs in the market or unless Walmart and other employers are illegally colluding by sticking to a low wage agreement - the value of productivity per hour is what workers at Walmart are negotiating. That is ludicrously utopian thinking. Reality does not conform to theory, there is always some gap between productivity and wages. Oh hell, it's been a growing gap, for the past 40 years. By eliminating jobs through manipulating the minimum wage so thoughtlessly, you would destroy vital segments of the job market that serve a purpose. No, I ensure that jobs go to people who actually need them. Besides, teenagers earning spending money can shovel snow off the books, or any number of other small jobs that they already do without recourse to an official employment contract.
- danenania 14y agoOf course there's a gap between productivity and wages. It's called profit. If a company doesn't make some profit off an employee's endeavors, why would they hire him/her? And if this gap, as you call it, is too high for the American workforce in general, for millions and millions of people, it would mean there is tremendous money to be made by companies willing to pay higher and so capture a portion of this surplus. The real reason that Americans are so exploited economically is because they lack the ability to reason about economics and are easily fooled by fallacious claims that benefit the most powerful at their own expense. The minimum wage is just a minor example among countless schemes designed to make the poor, working, middle, and even upper middle classes feel they are being aided by government policies while they are actually being copiously robbed in broad daylight.
- likeclockwork 14y agoThere is no negotiation. This is Walmart, not silicon valley. You don't like what we're paying? Starve, see if we care, we'll find someone who will work for half what we offered you and let us throw paint on him to boot. These jobs aren't taken by people whose needs are taken care of and are just looking for a little 'pocket money' or some gas so they can take the old car around and see their buddies on weekends.
- illuminate 14y ago"Starve, see if we care" Even if they like what Walmart is paying, their workers are still on food stamps.
- Nursie 14y agoAnd there is the issue! The rest of us, through taxes, are already subsidising the big corps and their minimum wage employees. We do this because people shouldn't have to starve in the modern world, but where people are employed we shouldn't need to. By forcing a raise in the minimum wage we stop the employer from taking from our collective pocket to support their broken business model.
- nathan_long 14y agoBut what's the root issue? Worker X is not able to produce value of more than $X an hour. Do we mandate he/she is paid more anyway, or do we try to train and educate a workforce that can produce more value?
- sergiosgc 14y agoYou wrongly assume the job market is a perfect market. It's not; there are barriers to entry, barriers to exit and lots of asymmetric negotiation positions.
- crusso 14y agoNobody said it's a perfect market. It's not a market dominated by monopolies either. The heavy handed solutions provided by minimum wages and other government measures doesn't help matters. They mask some problems while creating many others due to economic dislocation. In the end, masterminds planning all our lives and trying to create utopia on earth have never done better than following simpler rules of law and letting people deal with each other in a free market capitalistic system.
- sergiosgc 14y agoSorry, the GP reasoning assumes a perfect market, when stating that people are free to choose another employer if the current one is not paying enough. What wasn't stated in my comment is that the market is not perfect because of monopolistic behaviour. You kick off your argument with two misinterpretations of my comment and the GP's. The market is illiquid, for example, because of exit/entry costs associated with relocation, such as selling your home at underwater values. This is one example of the factors I mentioned. Others abound. The utopia/mastermind argument falls flat when you consider whether the US model is ahead of social-democrat states such as Denmark or Sweden. A cursory look at stats such as infant mortality rates or % of population below the poverty line strongly suggests the "mastermind" model is better.
- crusso 14y ago* The utopia/mastermind argument falls flat when you consider whether the US model is ahead of social-democrat states such as Denmark or Sweden* If we're doing a comparison, we need to compare across other utopian states. You need to throw in Greece, Italy, Portugal, the Soviet Union, North Korea, etc. You don't just get to cherry pick a couple of the few reasonable successes on your side of the ledger. Furthermore, you have to realize that there's a memetic/genetic difference in Denmark vs the US. We can no more adopt the rules and policies of Denmark here than the US can impose its style of democracy on Afghanistan. Finally, I would argue that countries like Denmark receive an amazing amount of benefit from other countries like the United States which provide most of the defense and technological advances that give them a cozy safe environment in which they get to spend most of their money on social programs.
- gdilla 14y agoRaising the minimum wage a little will help. If you're poor(ish), you basically spend every dollar you earn to survive. Canada has min wages around $10, and you can still buy a bigmac for the about the same as the US. Their sky has not fallen. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_minimum_wages_in_Canada http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_minimum_wages_in_Canada
- Sambdala 14y agoIt's likely that variation in productivity accompanied the rise in productivity. You're not much more (in real terms) productive than a bored teenager in 2013 than you were in 1993, but the most productive people in 2013 may be an order of magnitude more productive than the most productive people in 1993.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoOh, I contest that. It depends heavily on how you employ the bored teenager. Employ him at flipping burgers and he's obviously "unproductive" as ever was in 1993. Employ him at data-entry and he's the human component in an immensely valuable computation. What he still lacks in the latter case is bargaining power: the ability to walk out of his job and bring the vast computation to a quick halt. (Which is why unionization of a lot of low-level white-collar workers would really help, and would probably save us a lot of stupid talk on the subject of "My oh my, whatever should the government do!" Strong organized labor is how you keep government out of the labor market, at least if you don't want the working class to starve.)
- crusso 14y agoStrong organized labor is a de facto part of the Democratic party. The Democratic party really has become synonymous with the Federal Government itself, as their purposes of building power at the expense of individual sovereignty appear to be fairly close in alignment. What will get us somewhere is allowing people to realize that each of us is responsible for his or her own advancement in life. Sitting on the couch watching sports and reality TV every afternoon and evening has consequences. Majoring in bullshit ethnic and cultural studies in college has consequences. Measures like the minimum wage, welfare, the Community Reinvestment Act, and food stamps mask the relationship between real world actions and their economic consequences. This misalignment causes markets to warp more and more over time. To compensate, new mastermind policies are created to mask those effects. Eventually the economic dislocation becomes so bad that the system fails. This is what happened to Greece. This is what's happening in the US wrt the Debt.
- nathan_long 14y ago>> Or it could turn out Wal-Mart employees actually do produce $10/hour of value, and the company was just being exploitative all along... Your assumption is that it's immoral for an employer to make a high margin on labor. My assumption is that it's foolish for an employer not to make a high margin. My employer had better be getting tens of thousands more out of my efforts than what they pay me, or they shouldn't have hired me. That margin will be in flux month to month while my salary is constant, so there had better be some wiggle room or I'll be fired. It's not immoral to sell a Star Wars action figure for 10x what you bought it for, is it? Why is labor different?