3 ms·
"So, you will ring fence certain jobs as only for people without families? Perhaps like paper rounds?" No, what the heck did you read that gave you that idea a
by protomyth 14y ago
"So, you will ring fence certain jobs as only for people without families? Perhaps like paper rounds?"
No, what the heck did you read that gave you that idea about what I said? Employers decide everyday how much experience they need.
"But if a job is available to a teenager it is available to the fifty year old who just got laid off and unless it's working in a strip bar, is likely to be a better worker all round."
That is the problem with the upping of the minimum wage. Young workers get kicked out of entry jobs since the "lower wage / less experience" rate is pushed closer to "medium wage / experience" rate. So, employers aren't given a choice of setting the rate to something where part-time teenager is cost effective.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThe heck was " every job does not need to support a family" - but my contention is that unemployment is now structural - so every job will be contended for by someone who does need to support a family, and will be presumably more experienced, better qualified etc, than the student. In which case the student, or working mum, or immigrant family will usually lose out to the better qualified candidate. I agree that minimum wages rises cost jobs. But The jobs are going anyway - software is eating the jobs as well as the world. There will not be enough jobs to go round. And as jobs are the current way to spread wealth creation, we need to Find ways other than jobs to distribute wealth. How to do that I do not know - but we have to get out of a cycle of thinking full employment is the answer. My suggestion is that raisng the minimum wage hard will sweep away the jobs at the margin, clear out the weaker companies and business models that depend on subsidised labour and force us to deal with the problems head on, a situation that usually leads to cleaner and more effective solutions. But that is a political decision for each country - Sweden will take a different approach to the problem than Dubai or USA. But we all face the same problem. Edit: refactoring
- twoodfin 14y agobut my contention is that unemployment is now structural Funny how now unemployment is structural, thus nothing politicians can do anything about. When the other party was running things during the last recovery, sustained unemployment around 8% would not have been called structural, it would have been called evidence of lousy economic policy.
- protomyth 14y agoFirst, unemployment is structural is bunk. Second, your solution is to kill all the jobs and then think of some new solution? All those small businesses that are getting buy will be killed and then so will everything else. Software dies when no one is around who can pay for it.
- shard972 14y ago> But The jobs are going anyway - software is eating the jobs as well as the world This sounds very familiar, it reminds me of the arguments from the technocrats back during the industrial revolution who made the argument that that machines and factories, by making people more efficient would cost people their jobs and would lead to massive unemployment as human jobs would be replaced by machine jobs. With hindsight its not hard to see that they were obviously wrong, the jobs that the machines and factories may have destroyed in the short term were more than made up by the jobs and economic growth that came with it in the long term. What do you think makes your argument different then those of the technocrats?
- pixl97 14y ago>With hindsight its not hard to see that they were obviously wrong, I won't say they we're wrong, yet. The industrial revolution is not over.