3 ms·
Your argument assumes that all the increased that all the extra spending from people at the minimum wage goes to good produced by minimum wage workers, which I
by Symmetry 14y ago
Your argument assumes that all the increased that all the extra spending from people at the minimum wage goes to good produced by minimum wage workers, which I hope you would agree isn't true.
In theory you could find that the minimum wage could raise employment with tenuous assumptions[1], but there's no need to sit back and theorize in your arm chair when you can go out and collect actual data. And most studies show that the rises in the minimum wage do increase unemployment, though there have been a few studies that showed the opposite. But still, the consensus among economists about minimum wage is about as strong as it is among climatologists about global warming.
But that isn't the same as saying that a minimum wage is bad for poor people. If many people see their wages rise for every person who loses their job then maybe that's something we want. And the evidence does say that wage gains to the people making the new minimum exceed the wage loses of the people thrown out of work.
But since ~90% of the money for those wage gains ends up coming from higher prices, we'd be much better off just raising taxes and handing the money to people earning less than we think they should. That way the costs would fall progressively rather than repressively, and we wouldn't see any increase in unemployment at all.
EDIT: And while it's true that Australia has a very high minimum wage and low unemployment, most industries that would be minimum wage in the US have special exceptions from the minimum wage in Australia. The number of people earning 7$ an hour in Australia isn't that different per capita than in the US.
[1] That minimum wage industries are monopsomies and have similar cost structures.
- stretchwithme 14y agoIts easy to raise the minimum wage in the middle of an artificial economic boom. The destructive consequences don't show up until there is a drop in demand for labor. I doubt studies are designed to look beyond a few months after the increase for effects. If wages aren't drop when there is a dramatic increase in supply, there's no incentive to create businesses that can hire and train those people. Everyone that worked in the housing industry are now lacking marketable skills. They need retraining. It would be far better for the least valuable workers if we found some way to assist them that doesn't interfere with their ability to get a job. And we'd be doing that if there won't so many that don't understand how markets work. How much we pay in taxes is secondary to the high human costs of government interfering in critical markets like the labor market. The costs of this particular failure are focused entirely on the poorest among us. And most people are blind to how they are doing it to them.