5 ms·
A Day in the Life of a Digital Editor, 2013
- jseliger 14y agoThis is partially a response to yesterday's discussion about "A day in the life of a journalist:" http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5324429 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5324429.
- mpclark 14y agoI got down to the bit where the author tries to make it personal, then gave up. It's not about being personal or publishing private emails; it's about a respected publication approaching an established writer and asking for free product to sell on. Doesn't matter whether it was the poor dear's first fortnight in the job or if she'd been there 25 years.
- jseliger 14y agoThe short version of this is, "Don't be a journalist." There are so many people who want to be journalists, or to try to be, that The Atlantic thinks they'll work for free. Evidently many of them will. Anyone reading this should know that they need to seek another profession. Interestingly enough, in 2001 I was the co-editor-and-chief of my high school newspaper and thought about going into journalism. But it was obvious to me then that the Internet was going to destroy a lot of careers in journalism. It has. The only thing I still find puzzling is that some people want to major in journalism in college, or attempt to be "freelance writers."
- pyoung 14y agoI disagree. Better advice would be, if you want to be a journalist, "have a solid back-up plan" or "pursue it on the side". Even before the internet, it was a tough profession to be successful in. Now it is even tougher, but there are still individuals who manage to eek out lucrative and rewarding careers. This advice applies to any profession that has significant excess supply vs demand. Athletes, photographers, artists, actors, musicians etc... Even if an individual never makes it big (and most don't) these activities can be rewarding hobbies as long as expectations are managed properly.
- nutate 14y agoMy Dad was a musician his entire life. He's had other side jobs, but that was always his dream and big plan. I decided to go to engineering school and do music on the side. That has been much more successful for me money wise and in a way music wise as well. I've never had to compromise my (crappy) music to make a buck.
- nutate 14y agoBeing an established writer and a couple bucks will buy you a coffee. She asked, he said no, that would normally be the end of such an interaction. But he decided to publicize the fact that his writing was worth $0 and original writing would be worth $100. Quite a drop from the $350k he got paid by ABC for his pol pot interview in '87. He then sued them in 2002 for ~$20million, no idea how that case went, but I imagine not that well or else he'd probably be set. I'm that poor dear's boyfriend so I've obsessed over this odd case for a few days now. :D
- mpclark 14y agoOh, I'm sorry. Please pass on my apology for the "poor dear" thing. I realise it is patronising and unnecessary.
- nutate 14y ago"poor dear" isn't the worst she's been called w/r/t this bit of budgetary honesty coming to light. Nor has she read all that much of the commentary. She has read the pieces by Matt Yglesias, Ezra Klein, etc. The most recent one on Al Jazeera really pissed her off though, because that person had written for cheap or for free for the Atlantic in the past. Which seems disingenuous at best. Some of her writings for the Atlantic: http://www.theatlantic.com/sarah-kendzior/ http://www.theatlantic.com/sarah-kendzior/ Her article for Al Jazeera: http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2013/03/201331116423560886.html http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2013/03/20133111642... I think Sarah is trying to make a point about wage stagnation, but it is lost in a mist of links and appeals to our better selves. If money wasn't being actively redistributed towards the super wealthy there would be more money for individuals to pay for good writing. I think we can all agree on that. But in the mean time, you take what you can get and work with what you have.
- droopyEyelids 14y agoI had trouble understanding what point the author was trying to make. It feels a bit like the qualms you might feel during your first stint in management, where you basically enforce rules passed down from above. Where the good of 'increasing value' costs some of the well being of those you supervise, and you have to grow a big doublethink muscle to continue to think of yourself as a good person as opposed to a tool of exploitation, because, unfortunately the opportunities for win-win changes are actually few and far between.
- elemeno 14y agoThe point the author was making is that quality digital journalism is in a tough place right now, with small budgets to spend on features, but also the expectation that they'll churn out good work and worthwhile articles.
- joshAg 14y agothis video interview with harlan ellison seems relevant here (warning, language): https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=mj5IV23g-fE#t=14s https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&... perhaps profit sharingbased on unique views might be a solution to the problem.
- jschuur 14y agoDoes he get paid by the word? If you're responding to controversy, don't get too lengthy. It looks suspicious.
- csharpminor 14y agoPretty much all of the solutions that the author proposes for dealing with freelancers involved fixed fees per article. But if revenue is determined by unique visitors, why not just pay authors based on a royalty? This, perhaps coupled with an appropriate sized advance would ensure that authors were being rewarded for successful work, and that The Atlantic wouldn't be pouring money into stories that only get 1,000 hits. Given that major news can be broken over Twitter in 140 characters, paying by the word seems incredibly antiquated.
- smoyer 14y agoI'm siding with Thayer here ... I don't think he was "mean" to Olga (actually I thought it was refreshingly blunt), and Madrigal admits that you have to "feed the children". Edit: Olga's budget for purchased content is $12,000 a year? I'm going to assume her salary is significantly more than that, but why would you ask an expensive editor to "obtain/curate/manicure" work that was purchased so cheaply? It sounds like it really wouldn't be worth her time.
- pwthornton 14y agoThe problem I have with this piece is that it doesn't really offer any solutions and is basically a justification for trying to ask people for free work. Journalists rarely think about business models, which I think is one of the main reasons that journalism is doing so poorly. Some journalists abhor the idea of even thinking about how to support their work. I wrote a post with some suggestions on how we can pay for great writing: http://patthorntonfiles.com/blog/2013/03/06/paying-for-great-writing-in-the-internet-age/ http://patthorntonfiles.com/blog/2013/03/06/paying-for-great... My company got a reporting series funded on Kickstarter ($15,000), others are using Kindle Singles and there are other models to explore as well. I like what The Magazine is doing too. Sitting around saying, "well our freelancer budget is small" doesn't help the situation.
- nutate 14y agoOddly the Atlantic is doing pretty well. If Nate Thayer wasn't resting on the laurels of his 1987 Pol Pot interview he probably would've caught onto the joys of ePub tie ins, etc.
- jmount 14y agoWhite knight article.