2 ms·
"There are very few if any people who believe that it is impossible that global warming is not caused by man." Are you saying that nobody claims that the obser
by nkurz 18y ago
"There are very few if any people who believe that it is impossible that global warming is not caused by man."
Are you saying that nobody claims that the observed global warming could not be caused by natural causes, and thus the warming must have been caused by man? For if you are claiming this, I think you are wrong.
There are definitely a few very influential people claiming that climate change can only have been caused by man: "Only anthropogenic forcing of climate, however, can explain the recent anomalous warming in the late 20th century." http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/pubs/jones2004/jones2004.html http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/pubs/jones2004/jones2004.html
This is from the abstract of a paper co-authored by Michael Mann, the lead author of the IPCC report on climate change.
Or am I misreading your negations as well?
- dejb 18y agoUpmod for effort but I don't see this as equating to 100% certainty. The preceding sentences mention a variety of possible causal agents of climate change. In context the statement then is really 'Of the causes we have been able to identify - Only anthropogenic forcing of climate, however, can explain the recent anomalous warming in the late 20th century.' I also see 'can explain' is 'the we can explain'. You are encouraged not to use the first person in these sort of papers.
- Alex3917 18y agoYou're reading me correctly. My claims are basically that: A) I think that very few people actually believe that global warming could only be caused by anthropogenic forces. B) I've never actually heard anyone claim that global warming could only be caused by anthropogenic forces, so if people are even saying that then they are in a small minority. (The difference between A and B is that there may be people who say global warming can only be anthropogenic for political reasons even if they don't believe it. However, I'm saying that even the people who say this are a very small minority.) Now clearly your quote supports your claim that Mann is saying this, at least in the abstract. However, my guess is that he's saying this more for political reasons than scientific ones. Which IMHO is reasonable, considering that implementing a legally binding cap on carbon emissions is the best course of action considering what we know today.
- nkurz 18y agoAs the quote by Mann is from a published scientific paper rather than an editorial page, I can only hope that the statement is believed by the authors. I disagree that it would be reasonable to make an unsupported political statement in this context, thus I assume belief. The IPCC AR4 statement on this matter (presumably written or at least approved by Mann) has this to say: "The observed widespread warming of the atmosphere and ocean, together with ice mass loss, support the conclusion that it is extremely unlikely that global climate change of the past 50 years can be explained without external forcing and very likely that it is not due to known natural causes alone." p.39, http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar4/syr/ar4_syr.pdf http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar4/syr/ar4_syr.pdf While there is an important difference between 'impossible' and 'extremely unlikely', I think a journalist or lay reader could reasonably conclude that the scientific consensus (as represented by the IPCC report) is that warming could only be caused by anthropegenic forces.