3 ms·
Sometimes the EU regulators seem to have such forward thinking and great ideas. I don't feel this is one of those times. A browser selection screen as a legal r
by freehunter 14y ago
Sometimes the EU regulators seem to have such forward thinking and great ideas. I don't feel this is one of those times. A browser selection screen as a legal requirement, as well as the decision that they have to offer Windows without Media Player installed, seem to me to just be ridiculous requirements levied on Microsoft in an age where these decisions are increasingly irrelevant. There's no browser selection screen required for Windows RT or Windows Phone. Nor is there a requirement for browser selection on OSX, iOS, Linux distros, Android, or ChromeOS (imagine if that were the case...). In fact, the majority of those platforms require you to use the built-in browser, something Microsoft has never done with IE on the desktop. There's always been the choice of what software you want to install, up to the point when mobile devices gained popularity.
What the EU is trying to do is make competition more fair. What they're doing, in effect, seems to be making sure Microsoft has all the disadvantages the legislators can legally throw at them. I worked at a company that did this for employees it wanted to fire, making new requirements that couldn't possibly be met and when the employee failed they were fired for not meeting them. It's obvious the EU wants to fire Microsoft, in an age where competition has never been so fierce (and not due to a browser ballot).
- wladimir 14y agoI can't speak for the others but at least Android allows you to use any web browser you want (for example Firefox, Opera, Chrome). And it does give you a "browser selection screen" when you have multiple browsers installed AND open a link.
- Cthulhu_ 14y agoWindows never stopped anyone from installing an alternative browser either, or from picking a different default browser; the latter point is more of a usability point really (selection screen for every action or pre-set browser setting). Microsoft got the fine and was required to put this thing up (as it did with WMP) because IE was installed by default (Opera cried it was unfair competition, as Real did for WMP; neither benefited significantly from their complaints iirc, while MS had to bleed for them) and, technically, because it was so integrated with the OS you couldn't uninstall it. I honestly don't get why Microsoft / Windows is still the only party that has to do this, or why Microsoft himself hasn't struck back by having the EU put the same requirements on OSX and Linux. Then again, IE isn't available for OSX/Linux, so Microsoft wouldn't have anything to gain (unlike Opera / Real, that could compete with IE / WMP).
- masklinn 14y ago> I honestly don't get why Microsoft / Windows is still the only party that has to do this because Microsoft has (had) a natural monopoly position on desktop OS and was found to abuse this monopoly to distort related markets (web browsers) > why Microsoft himself hasn't struck back by having the EU put the same requirements on OSX and Linux Because the requirement is applied on "dominant position" grounds. Neither OSX nor Linux have ever reached anything close to a dominant position, let alone abused it.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- dsr_ 14y ago> Nor is there a requirement for browser selection on OSX, iOS, Linux distros, Android, or ChromeOS (imagine if that were the case...). In fact, the majority of those platforms require you to use the built-in browser Erm. iOS and ChromeOS require you to use the built in browser. In the Chrome case, there's a reasonable reason for that. None of the others you mention have that.
- jmduke 14y agoiOS requires you to have the built-in browser installed; they don't require you to use it. (You can download and install Chrome for iOS, but you can never remove Safari.) Still, this isn't a monopolistic concern until iOS has a monopoly. iOS's marketshare is nowhere near Windows' was when the anti-trust regulations were enacted.
- jfb 14y agoIn addition, Apple isn't using it's monopolistic control of one market to illegally gain share in another. Nor is Google.
- freehunter 14y agoChrome on iOS uses the Safari back-end. Only the GUI is different. Apple will not let you install a completely new browser on iOS.
- metajack 14y agoYou are not required to user either browser, and for example you can easily set the default browser on Android to Firefox. On iOS you must use the system provided webkit as other apps aren't allowed to download and execute code. Alternate browsers do exist, but these are based on UIWebView and don't perform as well as Safari.
- freehunter 14y agoiOS, ChromeOS, Windows RT, and Windows Phone all require you to use the default browser. I mentioned the Windows platforms in the prior sentence, the two Windows platforms not affected by this ruling.
- bluedanieru 14y agoI agree it isn't fair and I hope that, when Microsoft Windows no longer has monopoly status in the desktop OS market, these onerous regulations are rescinded.
- doktrin 14y ago"... when ..." Do you really consider Microsoft to currently have a monopoly as a desktop OS? IMO that is no longer the case.
- freehunter 14y agoAnd bear in mind that having a monopoly is not illegal. Abusing the monopoly to severely disadvantage competitors is.
- bluedanieru 14y agoWhich is what they were doing in the browser case right? And yes, I do think Windows is still a monopoly. I think its days as such are numbered and I think that is a good thing not just for the PC space but for Microsoft as well (in the long term, at least). But for now, yes, with market share north of 90% they still most definitely qualify as a monopoly.
- r00fus 14y agoThey still have a monopoly. Or do you consider 80%+ share[1] to be non-monopoly level of control? The latest interpretations of the Sherman Act [2] still think this level of control is a clear monopoly. [1] http://www.netmarketshare.com/operating-system-market-share.aspx?qprid=10&qpcustomd=0 http://www.netmarketshare.com/operating-system-market-share.... [2] http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Sherman+Anti-Trust+Act http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Sherman+Anti-T...
- coopaq 14y agoThey were found using monopolistic tactics to crush Netscape Navigator. Bill Gates et al were the decision makers. The web browser and Internet are a threat to closed proprietary operating systems like Windows and iOS where applications run exclusively rather than cross platform. Windows used to be where most all applications run. Apple iOS now has the same situation and you will notice Apple less and less happy to help applications run in a web browser and will continue to update Safari iOS less. But it was Microsoft that was found guilty in court for monopolistic anticompetitive actions. I think it's funny now that if you sell an operating system where you want to talk about number of apps on your OS how important it is those apps cannot run on another system. The low hanging fruit of apps that can easily be written as a web app run on every operating system thus giving no advantage to a proprietary operating system and really enable smaller indie developers. Microsoft is paying for its past sins, Apple is locking you up and being anticompetitive now, Google is ad spamming you, and I guess Facebook. Everybody is trying to make a buck. Sometimes the DoJ gets involved. See Microsofts recent efforts to get DoJ after Google :)
- weiran 14y ago> Apple iOS now has the same situation and you will notice Apple less and less happy to help applications run in a web browser and will continue to update Safari iOS less. Simply not true. Apple has always been supportive of web apps as an alternative to native apps. With iOS 6 Apple added a range of features including an indispensable remote debugger: http://www.mobilexweb.com/blog/iphone-5-ios-6-html5-developers http://www.mobilexweb.com/blog/iphone-5-ios-6-html5-develope...
- icebraining 14y agoThe problem wasn't that you didn't have a choice on Windows - you did. The problem was that by having a near monopoly on Windows, Microsoft gained an unfair (in the eyes of the EU) influence over the whole browser market, not just for their OS. The result were the dreaded "Optimized for IE" websites, since webmasters had no incentive to cross-test across browsers, and this made the life of the competition much harder. The same problem doesn't pose (for now) on mthe mobile space, since there are multiple different browsers competing - even if in different OSs each - which means the web devs are forced to remain more or less on spec.
- recoiledsnake 14y ago>The same problem doesn't pose (for now) on mthe mobile space, since there are multiple different browsers competing - even if in different OSs each - which means the web devs are forced to remain more or less on spec. Webkit is pretty much the defacto spec on mobile. http://www.glazman.org/weblog/dotclear/index.php?post/2012/02/09/CALL-FOR-ACTION%3A-THE-OPEN-WEB-NEEDS-YOU-NOW http://www.glazman.org/weblog/dotclear/index.php?post/2012/0...
- bd_at_rivenhill 14y agoWebkit is pretty much an open standard and can't be used by a dominant entity to disadvantage competitors.