5 ms·
I think more companies should be fined like this, as a percentage of their anual revenue. Except that I would further increase the percentage - up to 50% or eve
by tomp 14y ago
I think more companies should be fined like this, as a percentage of their anual revenue. Except that I would further increase the percentage - up to 50% or even 100%.
It's very simple: citizens go to jail, companies can't; so we have to make them pay, a lot. When fines are a fixed amount, the corporations have to simply earn more by committing the crime than they would have to pay if caught; banks are very adept at playing this game.
- Tichy 14y agoSo you would send people to jail for not giving dumb users a browser choice that is only going to confuse them anyway?
- slevin063 14y agothat is upto the court to deicde, tomp got a point that since companies cannot be jailed, they should be fined a percentage of their revenue!
- Tichy 14y agoThis case was a percentage of their revenue? But Tom called for 50% or 100% which seems excessive for such a nonsensical law.
- tomp 14y agoI was pointing out a general principle, not this specific case. What I had in mind is stricter punishment for more black-and-white crimes: not paying employee taxes/social contributions, not issuing receipts and thus avoiding sales tax, etc. I'm pretty sure that if fines were this high, compliance would become very high as well.
- tomp 14y agoLaws should be followed. If laws are bad, you should change the laws, not disregard them.
- kabdib 14y agoSome laws you have an obligation to not follow.
- learc83 14y ago>committing the crime If a someone in a corporation is actually committing a crime , then, yes they can go to jail. If they have committed some kind of civil offense or if it's a criminal offense with no jail term attached then they don't go to jail. There's nothing special about corporations that prevent the people in charge from serving jail time.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoServing time for a purely corporate offence is very very rare. Health and safety negligence is most common, but even the horse war scandal in Europe (where unfit horses were sold as beef and then into ready meals) it's unlikely and people there committed fraud as part of course of business
- learc83 14y agoThat's a matter of prosecutorial discretion. The point is they can serve jail time. What's the point of changing the law so that they can be fined 100% of revenue. The same discretion will still apply.
- tomp 14y agoIn many cases, it's much easier to prove that a corporation did something illegal than it is to research who exactly in the corporation was responsible (except for the CEO, of course, but to hold the CEO criminally liable for everything a company does would be too open to abuses).
- pasbesoin 14y agoA primary (if often unstated) function of corporations is to diffuse individual responsibility and accountability. Decisions -- where they are rational -- become a cost/benefit analysis. If you really want to deter the behavior, the costs have to outweigh the benefits. (Perhaps significantly enough to outweigh various arguments about what the true costs and benefits might be.) And... this still says nothing about the damage that may have been caused to victims, and compensation for same. (For example, take someone's health away in certain fashions, and no amount of money can replace it.)
- brg1007 14y agoThis fine is plain stupid. Why EU doesn't fine Google for the same thing on Android. Android is in a monopoly position in EU and I do not saw any broswer choice screen when I first start my Android phone.
- arethuza 14y agoAndroid's 61% market share in Europe is hardly a monopoly: http://www.nasdaq.com/article/apple-raises-market-share-to-53-ousting-android-from-top-spot-cm201499#.UTc3x1eaV8E http://www.nasdaq.com/article/apple-raises-market-share-to-5...
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThe browser choice option was merely one agreed solution to the problem that as owner of the ecosystem (windows) MA was not letting any other browsers in. The highly competitive marketplace for mobile devices gives you as a consumer a wide variety of choices of operating system, and each operating system (apart iOS) is adjusted by the operator to best fit their idea of market You can choose devices, you can choose different versions and setups of android. There is a competive market The fact that its not free as in speech is not the problem (it should be but)
- tomp 14y agoWell, the original ruling may have been stupid and might have become irrelevant by now. But the fine is very reasonable: MS didn't do what the courts ordered it to do. Plain and simple.
- masklinn 14y ago> Android is in a monopoly position in EU Not even close. It's in a majority position but nowhere near a monopoly. Although it can probably be considered to be a "dominant position", but then come the next part: 1. Has somebody complained 2. Is "Android" using its dominant position to distort the market
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThe browser choice option was merely one agreed solution to the problem that as owner of the ecosystem (windows) MA was not letting any other browsers in. The highly competitive marketplace for mobile devices gives you as a consumer a wide variety of choices of operating system, and each operating system (apart iOS) is adjusted by the operator to best fit their idea of market You can choose devices, you can choose different versions and setups of android. There is a competive market The fact that its not free as in speech is not the problem (it should be but)
- flexie 14y agoListen, 50 percent or 100 percent of revenues - that easily leaves you with a bankrupt company. That's not in the interest of consumers. Microsoft was fined around 1 percent of their global sales for a violation of the terms of a kind of a settlement in an old competition case (antitrust case). Microsoft already knew that if they violated the terms they would be fined up to 10 percent of their global revenues: http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-09-1941_en.htm?locale=en http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-09-1941_en.htm?local... Microsoft mostly complied with the terms of the settlement, but not entirely as the OP describes. In that light the 1 percent fine is probably not way off.