3 ms·
So... lets say we have this guy, lets call him "Mr. Shark". Mr. Shark notices that MtGox only has 107159 BTC trading volume. When converted into USD, that is a
by dragontamer 14y ago
So... lets say we have this guy, lets call him "Mr. Shark".
Mr. Shark notices that MtGox only has 107159 BTC trading volume. When converted into USD, that is about $5 Million. So... Mr. Shark learns that he can control the market price in any direction, with approximately only $5 million USD of investment.
Mr. Shark's strategy therefore, is to build up enough money to "spook" the market by controlling it for a full day. ~100,000 BTC would be enough to crash the market for a full day: and hopefully the spooked long investors will help create the crash afterwards. Mr. Shark would then make sure the majority of his bet is in the form of a Long Straddle. Mr. Shark rides the market up till BTC has hit some absurdly high value, maybe issue a press release or two to help fuel BTC's rise.
One day, Mr. Shark sells 100,000 BTC all at once on the Mt. Gox market. He cashes in at BTC's high price, then BTC crashes. (EDIT: For clarification... Mr. Shark loses some money here, on purpose).
Mr. Shark then cashes in on his Call Options portion of his Long Straddle, and makes money because the market went down.
Long story short: Mr. Shark wins a ton of money, and everyone who has "invested" into BTC these past few weeks loses their money to Mr. Shark. Mr. Shark leaves the market without any worries that investigators will be after him. (Its not like there is a Bitcoin version of the FTC)
Until Mt. Gox's volume gets high enough to resist an adversarial trader, or until there is some group in charge to make sure that blatantly adversarial trading doesn't happen on the Bitcoin market... the BTC currency will be too risky for me.
- nazgulnarsil 14y agoit's absurdly easy to beat the "wallstreet sharks" at their own game. Buy shares of an index and hold.
- nandemo 14y ago> One day, Mr. Shark sells 100,000 BTC all at once on the Mt. Gox market. He cashes in at BTC's high price, then BTC crashes. If the the daily volume is about 100,000 BTC, how do you expect to sell 100,000 at once at "the high price"?
- dragontamer 14y agoOn the contrary. Mr. Shark doesn't want to sell BTC at the high price. He just wants BTC to crash. Mr. Shark makes his money from options trading and short-selling. The $5 million / 100k BTC is seen as an investment, its the cost that Mr. Shark pays to have unilateral control over the market for a day. Short Selling is when Mr. Shark comes up to you and says "Hey, I'll give you $100 right now if I can borrow 10k bitcoins for a week. I promise I'll give the bitcoins back". Mr. Shark can now build up 100k BTC to sell without actually risking $5 million USD. Call options is when Mr. Shark comes up to you and says "Hey, I'll give you a BTC on Wednesday next week if you give me $20 today". Since Bitcoins cost $40 today, its a good deal, so you buy these contracts. On Saturday, Mr. Shark crashes the market. He not only sells his 100k BTC, he short-sells more BTC. The BTC market panics, and BTCs drop down to pennies again. Come next Wednesday, Mr. Shark fulfills his contract. He buys a bitcoin for $1, and gives it to all of the people he sold Call options to, or participated in his Short-selling deal. Again, the $5 million is just the amount of money Mr. Shark is willing to lose to gain control of the market. Mr. Shark is making money through other means.
- nandemo 14y agoYour example still doesn't add up. AFAIK there's no liquid market for BTC derivatives, but let's assume it comes to exist. > Call options is when Mr. Shark comes up to you and says "Hey, I'll give you a BTC on Wednesday next week if you give me $20 today". Since Bitcoins cost $40 today, its a good deal, so you buy these contracts. That sounds... unusual. A more usual formulation would be "I give you the right to buy BTC from me for $20 on Wednesday if you give me $x today". The fair value of x (the premium) depends on other factors besides the current price. But, more importantly, there's no "good deal": if you set $x below the fair value then the buyers will arbitrage the hell out of you. E.g. if the fair price for the call option above is greater than $20 but you sell it for $20, then a buyer will happily take your offer: they sell 1 BTC short and get $40 in cash, pay you $20 and put the remaining $20 in the bank. Come Wednesday, they withdraw $20 (keeping the interest) and use that to cover their short sell: at worst they have to buy the stock from you for $20 (but they still make money on the interest), at best the stock has crashed and they make even more.
- daliusd 14y agoYou are absolutely right and... Bitcoin FAQ covers this: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/FAQ#Does_Bitcoin_guarantee_an_influx_of_free_money.3F https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/FAQ#Does_Bitcoin_guarantee_an_inf... See "As an investment, is Bitcoin a sure thing?".
- dragontamer 14y agoAnd now we've got the reason why the USD is better. Because the FTC is the government agency designed to stop bull$$$$ like Mr. Shark, and throw people like him into jail. Who is to protect me when Mr. Shark come after bitcoins?
- daliusd 14y agoThis. IMHO the main difference between bitcoin and dollar is that dollar is centralized and bitcoin is not. Question is who you trust more.
- scotty79 14y ago> One day, Mr. Shark sells 100,000 BTC all at once on the Mt. Gox market. He cashes in at BTC's high price, then BTC crashes. Then Mr. Stingray buys cheap bitcoin for 5mil and the story goes on. And small fish like us tag along for the ride, trying to figure out when to buy and when to sell. I thought that's exactly how stock market works, and commodities market and every market that people with money use for "investment". Plus sometimes some ridiculous rules about selling or buying just before or after making positive or negative hype that helps to punish 3% (my guess) of most obvious cases when that happens.
- zby 14y agoIt all depends on how people will react - if they panic he'll maybe double his investments, if not he'll lose it. If you had 50% probability to these two outcomes would you take the gamble? I guess you are sure that there is some way to make people panic if you have 1 daily MtGox volume in BTC - but it is only because you don't have it and you imagine that if only you had it you'll be able to fool all the bitcoin market players.